AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

Unlikely Pair

Page 112

by Chelle Sloan

“Hey, Mav,” I say, but before I can say anything else, he and Adalyn are skipping, hand in hand, toward the door of the studio.

“How are they that independent at four?” I say as I hold Adalyn’s pink dance bag.

“I don’t know. But let’s remember this when they’re sixteen.”

It’s like at the same moment, Sutton and I realize the situation. We haven’t seen each other since I kissed her goodbye on her doorstep. We’ve talked, sure, but that was text or a few phone calls I snuck in during our return trip to Vegas for Game 5.

Do I kiss her? I mean, not the kind of kiss we shared in the bed of my truck, but on the cheek? I planned on sitting by her in class—that was happening even before this crazy scheme we concocted—but do I hold her hand? Part of the purpose of this was to get the Erikas of the world away from me. But now that we’re in it, I’m frozen and unsure of what to do.

Thank goodness Sutton makes the first move. Because somehow, like always, she knows exactly what I need to calm my nerves.

“Hey you,” she says, stepping into my space before rising on her tiptoes and kissing my cheek. Just the quick brush of her lips is enough to relax me and get me out of my head.

“Hey.” I reach for her hand with my free one, locking our fingers together, but not moving toward the studio just yet.

“Was that okay?”

The fact that she’s always checking on me, making sure I’m moving at a comfortable speed, is something I’m not taking for granted.

“It’s fine,” I say. “I didn’t know what the protocol was or I would’ve done it first.”

Her smile is interrupted by the sound of a slamming car door that has us both checking to see who it is. And of course, who else would it be besides Erika.

“Show time,” Sutton whispers.

“What?”

I’ve barely processed what she said before Sutton has her arms around my neck, kissing me like she did on Saturday. Only, standing up.

We’re at a children’s dance studio…we’re at a children’s dance studio…

A Pandora’s box opened for me that night with Sutton. We didn’t do anything besides kiss and some roaming hands over the clothes, but the amount of times I’ve replayed those moments between us—in my bed, in the shower…so many showers—is embarrassing to even think about, let alone admit.

I’ve always been a physical touch guy. Hailey used to tell me it’s my love language. After she was gone, I locked that part of myself away. But now? Feeling Sutton against me? Her mouth on mine? Her taste of mint and cherries? That part of me has now woken up, and I don’t see it going to sleep anytime soon. Especially when she kisses me out of nowhere, even if it’s just for show.

“Well what do we have here?” Erika says as Sutton gives me one more peck before lowering herself back to a fully standing position.

“Sorry, Erika,” Sutton says, acting shy and embarrassed. “Just got carried away I guess.”

Erika looks back and forth between us like she’s having a tennis match with herself before asking, “Are you two, like, dating?”

“We are,” I say confidently, pulling Sutton into me. “Sorry about the PDA. Just so little time to steal a moment with the kids around, you know?”

“Of course I know,” she says, but the tone doesn’t match her words. I’ve heard from both my mom and Sutton that Erika is already through husband number two. Oh! She should meet Sutton’s mom.

“Well, sorry again,” I say before nodding toward the door. “We should be going in. Class is starting.”

I try to start walking, Sutton’s hand in mine, but Erika steps in front of me so fast I nearly run her over. “Come on, Asher. Her? Really? If you were lonely, I told you where you could find me.”

My stomach turns over and a loud “excuse me!” comes from Sutton. I don’t see her being the kind to take off an earring and go after a person—a.k.a. Hailey’s usual move when a girl hit on me in college—but I do step in front of her, planning to block any blow.

Except the fact that I’m six foot three and two hundred fifteen pounds doesn’t stop my pseudo-girlfriend.

Fuck…we’re about to get the cops called on us in a dance studio parking lot.

“I need you to listen and listen good,” Sutton snaps. “He’s not interested. If he wasn’t seeing me, he still wouldn’t be interested. You grabbed his ass in the middle of a children’s dance class. How in the world is that appropriate? It’s desperate. Like you. And your extensions. Which are hideous by the way. So please, Erika, leave us alone. Go try and snag husband number three somewhere else. Oh, and never talk to Asher, or me, ever again.”

A few “gahs!” leave Erika’s mouth before she storms inside the dance studio, throwing the door open so hard she nearly breaks it off the hinges.