AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

After Further Review

Page 30

by Alexandria Arden

Elliott’s entire demeanor changes when she spots me. By the time they reach our table, she’s more closed off, nervous even, so different from the vibrant person on stage. Raskolnikov wraps his arms around his wife and gives her a sloppy kiss on the cheek as she bats him away. He’s always been obsessed with her, and now is no different. He sits, pulling Kat onto his lap to make room for me to join them at the table. Bridget and Logan sit as well, leaving the chair next to me the only one open. Elliott shuffles, her eyes locking on Bridget, who only gives her a wink. Eventually, she sits next to me, her movements stilted and uncomfortable.

Should I not have come? I hate the way she shuttered in on herself when she saw me. Maybe I’ve been reading the situation between the two of us wrong. As much as I’ve insisted we could be friends, I’ve interpreted our daily texting and flirty interactions as barely held back restraint, an attraction we both wish we could act on but know we can’t. Toeing a line but never crossing it.

Maybe Elliott really does just want to be friends, though, and me showing up here has made her realize the length of my feelings.

I knew I was going to fuck this up.

“Hey, Elliott,” I say with forced casualness. She turns to face me, finally, those green eyes staring me down. I squirm in my chair, but can’t look away.

“Hi, Aidan. I didn’t know you were coming.”

“I was hanging with my sisters first, but I couldn’t miss Wednesday karaoke.”

The whole table knows I miss Wednesday karaoke all the time, and only came because of her, but no one says anything. Raskolnikov and Kat are lost in their own flirty conversation, and Logan is too googly-eyed for Bridget to notice anything else. Bridget, on the other hand, is completely aware of what’s going on, if the light dancing in her eyes is any indication.

“What are you going to sing, Aidan?” Bridget asks, saving Elliott and me from our awkward conversation. Neither of us knows how to take the texts we send every day and translate them into real life. “And don’t say you don’t sing. That is the entire point of being here.”

“Oh, I sing. I started Wednesday night karaoke. I’ve got a great rotation.”

Logan groans. “Not again.” Bridget looks between the two of us with glee, but all I can focus on is the feel of Elliott’s eyes on me, watching me intently.

“Oh, yes,” I say with a bit more enthusiasm than necessary.

“Aidan’s about to scream sing that ten-minute song by Teegan Smith,” Logan warns the group.

Bridget claps in delight, and Elliott’s lips twitch, like she can’t help but be amused. Raskolnikov and Kat take notice, joining the conversation.

“I didn’t have you pegged as such a die hard Smithie,” Bridget says.

“Aidan exclusively sings Teegan Smith,” Kat informs us. “It’s his specialty.”

“I’m gonna go get back on the lineup. I’ll put you down, too,” Bridget tells me before standing and heading to the emcee station with Logan in tow.

“I need more vodka,” Raskolnikov proclaims. “You guys want anything?”

“Vodka soda,” Elliott requests.

“I don’t—” I start

“Drink during the season. We know,” Raskolnikov finishes for me. He and Kat head to the bar, leaving Elliott and me alone together.

“So,” I say.

She laughs. “So…”

“Are you having fun tonight?” She nods. “Am I—did I—” I’m not sure how to ask her if she’s upset that I came, if the way she’s shrunk into herself since I got here is because of my presence.

“What?” she asks, a small twinkle in her eye that I remember from our night together.

I loose a breath. “Sorry if I made it weird. Coming here, I mean.”

She furrows her brow. “No, no. You didn’t, I mean. Am I being weird?”

I laugh. “No. You just seem a little uncomfortable. Like, maybe you would have more fun if I wasn’t here. I can go hang out with another group and let you have fun with Bridget. Rascal and Kat, too.” I try to sound nonchalant, like it doesn’t matter to me either way, but I don’t pull it off. Instead, I sound defeated and a little sad.

Elliott reaches out her hand, placing it on top of mine where it sits on the table before realizing what she’s done and pulling it away. “I’m sorry. It’s totally fine. I’m glad you’re here.” She smiles, and my shoulders relax. “I’m just in my head about hanging out with players. I’ll get over it.”

I return the smile and lean in to her. “It isn’t a big deal, stripes. You’re not doing anything wrong, and even if you were, no one here is going to say anything. Let loose. Have fun. I’ll be sober, anyway. I can take care of you and make sure you don’t do anything you’ll regret.”