Page 44
“I thought about getting you a bouquet of flowers since it’s kind of our first date and everything, but I figured you might like this better.” He hands me the packet and I look at it.
It’s mixed perennial wildflower seeds.
My heart stutters and I fling my arms around his neck, bringing my lips an inch from his and smiling.
“I love them. Thank you.” I peck his lips and he returns the kiss, gently and sweetly.
“Come on, I’ve got our date all set up.”
I kiss him one more time, then slip the flower seeds into my pocket, close my door, and follow him off my porch. Cooper reaches for my hand and twines his fingers between mine as we walk.
“I can’t believe you haven’t asked yet where we’re going or what I have planned,” he says with a laugh.
“Hey, I’ve changed. I came to Palm Island without a plan and that worked out pretty well for me.”
I glance over at him with a grin and he returns it.
“I guess you have. You didn’t need to change though. I never minded you being a little uptight and obsessed with having a plan.”
“I know you didn’t.” I squeeze his hand. “And I’m glad to hear that, because not knowing what I’m doing with my life is starting to make me itchy as fuck. I think I’m getting past the burnout and I’m going to need to start a new five-year spreadsheet soon.”
Without consciously thinking about it, I brace for the mood to shift, for Cooper to pull away or tense up, but he doesn’t. I look at him again and he looks just as relaxed and happy as he did five seconds ago, and something inside me loosens a little.
“I’m sorry for being a dick at your place the other night and for saying that shit. I was scared, I think,” he confesses.
“Scared of what?” I know he’s only human, but he has this superhuman way of staying so unruffled that I forgot anything could bother him.
“Same thing I’ve been scared of since the night I worked up the guts to ask you on a date, sweetness.” He drops my hand and puts his arm around my shoulders instead, tugging me closer as we walk and kissing the top of my head. “You’ve always been too good for me, and you had a bigger future than I was ever going to be able to keep up with. It always felt like a matter of time before I was going to lose you.”
Years’ worth of unresolved guilt and regret churn in my stomach, along with some of that same frustration and muted anger I felt the other night in my kitchen.
“When I got that offer from Switzerland, I asked you what I should do, and you told me to go,” I remind him. “You didn’t even hesitate. You didn’t have to think about it for a second.”
I breathe a little faster, and my voice gets a little louder, and Cooper’s arm tightens around me, unwavering.
“I loved you enough to let you go,” he says calmly. “And then after eight years I loved you too much to let you back in.”
“I didn’t even want to say yes to that stupid bachelor thing, but Boston asked and I looked at you and it was like you didn’t even care. I think I was testing you or something,” I mutter, just as annoyed at myself that it took us this long to be honest about the breakup and our feelings as I am with him.
“Well, I’ve never been very good at taking tests,” he says with a chuckle.
“Eh, you choked in the first half, but I think you aced it in the end. We’re here, after all, finally talking about this shit, going on a proper date. Coop, you’ve gotta know that I’ve spent every day of the last eight years wondering if I made the wrong choice. The minute I stepped off the ferry and saw you, I felt like I was getting a second chance.”
“Me too.” He kisses my head again.
I relax into him, not bothering to pay much attention to where we’re going, trusting him to lead the way. Everything we’ve just said to each other slowly filters through my brain, and one thing stands out.
I loved you too much to let you back in.
“Hey, Coop?” I say softly. “I still love you too.”
LYRIC
I lead Yuri up the slope of the small hill, switching back to holding his hand so I can help him past the spots where it’s a little bit steep.
I still love you.
I still love you.