Page 13
"Scotch, neat. The oldest thing you've got open," I tell him.
"And a glass of water."
He brings both. I slide the water along the zinc until it stops beside her champagne, and I leave it there without comment. Then I pick up my scotch, and for a full minute we sit like two strangers who happened to choose neighboring stools.
Around us, Balthazar is winding down. A busboy is stacking chairs near the back, and the last few tables are talking in the low voices people use late at night.
"Thank you for dinner, Mr. Pierce," Harper says to her glass. Her voice is steady and very polite.
"I'm sorry about all of that. It wasn't the evening I had in mind."
"You have nothing to apologize for," I say.
"I announced my own breakup over a birthday cake. That's a scene, by any definition," she says.
"I've sat through a great many scenes. That wasn't one," I say.
"Alistair…” I say.
“I’ve bought you and your friends dinner and watched my son break your heart. I think we're past Mr. Pierce."
That turns her head.
It's the first time I've had her face this close with nothing between us but twelve inches of air. Her eyes are big and round and very blue, with lashes so long that they throw small shadows on her cheeks, and they're a little glassy from the champagne. She's flushed along her cheekbones. She isn't sloppy, and she isn't crying. She looks like a woman who's been holding a heavy door shut for three hours and has just noticed her arms are tired.
"Alistair," she says slowly, testing it.
I take a swallow of scotch, because I need something to do with my mouth.
She catches her reflection in the mirror behind the bottles, and her hand goes up to the tiara. Her fingers work at one of the pins.
"I should take this ridiculous thing off," she says.
"Leave it on. It's your birthday for another forty minutes," I say.
Her hand stops. She looks at me, then at the mirror, and the corner of her mouth lifts. A dimple appears in her cheek, the first real one I've seen all night. She lowers her hand to the bar.
"Forty minutes," she says. "You're very exact."
"It's an occupational habit," I say.
She picks up the water, to my satisfaction, and drinks a third of it. I give it a moment. Then I ask her something easy.
"What did you wish for?" I ask.
"When I blew out the candles?" she asks.
"Yes," I say.
She laughs under her breath and shakes her head, and a wave of brunette hair slides forward over her shoulder.
"You're not supposed to tell. It won't come true," she says. She turns the champagne glass a quarter turn on its napkin.
"It's not coming true anyway, so here it is. I wished he'd walk in. I stood there with thirty candles and that text message sitting in my phone, and I wished he'd walk through that door and tell me it was a mistake." She presses her lips together.
"It's pathetic. You can say so."
I don't say so. I don't tell her it isn't, either, because she'd know I was being kind, and she's had enough people being kind to her tonight. I hold her eyes and let the wish be what it was.