Page 123
He doesn't sit. He takes the folded paper out of his shirt pocket, opens it with one shake, and drops it on my desk. It slides across the walnut and stops against my blotter.
I don't have to pick it up. I can read the highlighted line from where I'm standing. Balthazar. Two names. My house at 12:11. Walter's handwriting has been on my expense reports for fifteen years, and this is the first time it has ever been used against me.
"Walter keeps very good records," I say.
"That's all you've got?" Cole stares at me. "That's the first thing out of your mouth?"
"What would you like me to say first?"
"I'd like you to say it isn't true." He laughs, and his voice cracks on it.
"No. I wouldn't. I'd like you to say it. You took her to punish me. Just say it."
"Cole."
"You've thought I was a disappointment since I was twelve years old," he says. He's walking now, from the desk to the window and back again, the way he did as a boy when he was building up to asking for something.
"You never said it. You never had to. You'd look at my report card and sign it and hand it back without a word. You'd come home at eleven and look in my door and leave. You gave me a car, and a loft, and a seat, and you never once looked at me like I'd earned any of it. Now you've finally found a way to say it out loud, haven't you? You took the one thing that was mine."
"She was never a thing, and she wasn't yours."
He stops walking.
I could make this easy. I could tell him I gave a distressed employee a ride, that she was upset, that it was late and she didn't want to be alone, that Walter wrote down the wrong address. He would half believe it, because he'd want to. I've been lying to my son by omission for fifty-seven days, and I'm done adding to it.
"I've wanted her for three years," I tell him, "and I kept away from her for three years, because she was with you."
He looks at me as if I've hit him.
"Three years," he repeats.
"I sat across from her at my own table every Thanksgiving, and I didn't let myself look at her for longer than it takes to pass a dish. I never said one word to her that I couldn't have said in front of you. Not once, Cole. Not until the night you ended it with a text and left your chair empty at her birthday dinner."
"That's supposed to make it better?"
"No. It's supposed to be the truth."
He comes back to the desk and leans on it with both hands. His eyes are red.
"Then tell me the rest of the truth," he says.
"That night. That first night. You went from Balthazar to the house with my girlfriend, four hours after I ended it. Tell me it had nothing to do with me."
This is the question I've been answering for myself since the morning I woke up alone with a tiara on my nightstand.
"That first night," I say, "was some of it anger at you? Yes. I won't lie to you about that."
For a second he doesn't move. Then he straightens up slowly, and something flickers across his face that looks almost like relief.
"Some of it was anger at me," he says, louder. Much louder. He turns his head toward the door as if he wants the whole floor to hear it.
"Some of it was anger at me! There it is. Thank you. That's all I came up here for."
"That isn't all of it," I say.
"It's all I need." He points at me.
"You took her to get back at me. You just said so."