AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

The Darkness You Crave

Page 36

by Evelyn Austin

The air inside the cave is cold and smells like brine and wet stone. Under my boots, the floor is slick, polished over time by the constant ebb and flow of the ocean. It’s clear that when the tide is high, this entire space is swallowed by the ocean.

As we move deeper into the cave, the narrow passage opens into a large, vaulted rotunda that feels more like a buried cathedral than a natural cavern.

The others are already here—at least two dozen people who form a silent ring of masked figures. No one speaks. The only sound comes from the flicker of fire from the torches that line the walls.

This whole thing is giving Indiana Jones and the Temple of Doom, and I swear to God, if they try to rip my heart out, I’m swimming to Catalina Island. I’ll take my chances with the sharks.

Dax’s hand drops to my lower back, guiding me toward the center of the circle where a sliver of daylight filters through a crack in the ceiling.

My anxiety is matched only by a sense of awe. This is wild. I seriously can’t believe all this has been hidden in the Malibu cliffs this whole time.

Dax steps back, leaving me alone in the center. The circle presses in, their masked faces blending with the shadows. One of them steps forward, holding a small gold bowl filled with a thick, dark liquid that smells like copper and crushed herbs.

I twist around, my eyes searching for Dax. But with his robe and veil on, he blends into the surrounding darkness. And, for some reason, not knowing where he is makes my pulse spike. I’m completely alone in a room full of faceless figures.

I turn back to the person holding the bowl. It looks like a man—tall, broad-shouldered. He’s also veiled, but there are no other distinguishing marks or tattoos that I can see. The Priest, I name him.

He dips his thumb into the bowl, then presses it against my lips—hard—tracing the seam of my mouth with the bitter-tasting ink. I twist my head away and clamp my jaw shut so I don’t gag.

The Priest leans in closer, his voice dropping to a low, gravelly whisper. “Now, show them you can keep a secret,” he says. “Whatever the tide gives, it eventually reclaims. Today, it gives voice to your secrets.”

What does that even mean?

The Priest steps back, melting into the ring of masked figures. Then the circle begins to hum in a low, rhythmic tone. A short, slender figure steps forward first—a female, I’m guessing. She leans forward, her voice trembling, and says, “I watched my brother drown and was too scared to save him.”

I swallow hard, but say nothing as she moves away. The person next to her steps forward, a man. His voice is cold and devoid of emotion. “I stole money that would have saved a hundred families from the street.”

The next person, “I’ve killed, and I’d do it again just to feel the rush.”

I pull back. What the fuck?

My heart hammers against my ribs. I know that voice. Don’t I? It sounds familiar, but it’s hard to place with the humming in the background.

The circle keeps going like that, a slow, agonizing rotation of obscured faces. One by one, they lean in and whisper things that make my skin crawl—betrayals, thefts, a hit-and-run—every secret worse than the last.

When it’s done, and everyone has spoken, the air in the rotunda feels heavy, stale. Used up.

“Now, it’s your turn,” the priest says. “What secrets do you offer the tide?”

He’s standing directly in front of me, staring at me through his veil. He doesn’t move, but I can feel the anticipation of the two dozen people behind him. They’ve offered me their secrets, and now they want mine.

I swallow hard, my throat dry. I think of the giant, sprawling house in Calabassis. I think of my mom’s “wellness retreats” and all the empty wine bottles discarded in the recycling bin outside.

“My mom is an alcoholic, and sometimes…” I whisper. “I buy her wine, just to get some peace.” I pull in a shaky breath, the smell of brine filling my lungs. “I do it to stop her begging, even if it’s just for a few hours.”

The priest takes a step toward me, the air between us sparking. He reaches out and catches my jaw between his thumb and forefinger, tilting my head back until my throat is exposed.

“Nice try, princess.” His voice is a dark caress that slithers down my spine.

Sin.

He dips his head, the fabric of his veil brushing against my forehead, his free hand sliding into my robe, and up my thigh, beneath my leather skirt. “You can do better than that. Dig deep. Give us your darkest shame…”

I swallow, my heart beating a frantic tempo against my ribcage.

My darkest shame…

I could lie, but I’m not sure it’d do me any good. He’d clock it instantly. Sin seems to have an uncanny ability to read me, and I know he’ll just continue to pull confessions out of me until his sick curiosity is satisfied.