Page 92
“So, I think I’m going to see if we can stay with my sister for a little bit,” I say, the subject change not exactly trending in the sexy category.
“No, I’ll reach out to Aunt Sally and get us a room at Orchid Bay,” Eli counters. “It’ll be easier. They have everything we need for Mason. We can make it a little vacation.”
I try to smile, but it’s not a vacation. It’s all just so fucked up.
While Eli is packing up Mason’s diaper bag, I make some notes in my phone about things that were moved, wondering if we should call the police. Maybe they can make a report or just note that things were off here.
I’m going through my room now, and oddly, nothing looks to be out of place. Checking my closet, my drawers, the desk, and still nothing amiss.
Maybe I’m overreacting. Maybe the things in Mason’s room and the toys in the living room were like that when we left, and I’m just being paranoid.
Fuck, I hate that I’m questioning my own memory. I know what I saw, and I know someone has been in the house.
And that’s when I see it. Sitting on my pillow, a small black box tied with a red satin ribbon.
The wave of nausea nearly takes me down, and I have to keep myself from throwing up on the floor. My hand shakes as I reach for it, but I don’t need to open it to know what’s in the box.
It was a gift that was given to me the night Madeline found out about the affair. She was supposed to be gone another night for a work trip but showed up early.
At that time, it felt like a shock, but looking back, it was intentional. She knew her husband was having an affair, and this was her opportunity to catch him. I didn’t know it then, but I wasn’t his first, and this wasn’t the first time she’d walked in on something similar.
I hate that I felt bad for her for a split second and the way she looked so defeated and hurt by what her husband had done, but that’s when she turned her rage on me.
Screaming and throwing things, snatching the black box with the red ribbon off the dining room table, lobbing it forcefully at me.
But never once did she turn her hatred toward her husband. It was all directed at me.
Grabbing the box off my bed, I race into the hallway just as Eli is going into Mason’s room.
“I’m calling the police,” I announce, my words quiet but firm, not wanting to wake Mason.
“What happened?” Eli questions, brows pinched in confusion.
It feels awful having to relive this, but to have to relive it with my boyfriend makes it worse.
“She left this on my bed,” I say, holding out the box. “It was something her husband gave me…” My words get lost, not wanting to say them out loud. It’s embarrassing enough that I had an affair, and sharing those details hurts, but I don’t want to share how I got kicked out of their house, all the horrible things she said about me, and how she kept a gift her husband intended to give me.
It feels like she’s playing the long game here, and it’s disturbing.
The police show up about ten minutes after I make the call, with Mason thankfully sleeping through it all. It’s late, after ten, since we stayed at my sister and Jonah’s longer than planned, and now we’re dealing with this.
Eli lets them in, and while I’m still scared and upset, it’s starting to shift to anger, hating this woman for everything she continues to do.
I’m not sure what more she wants from me. I’ve admitted to the affair in front of the school board and multiple students and staff. I left the school without argument and have never contacted either of them until she started the threats on Instagram.
I’ve stayed away, but she won’t give up.
The police ask a few questions and walk around, turning their questions to Eli and me. We share that we did leave the back door open, but they assure us that doesn’t mean anyone can just come in.
They take notes of the threats on Instagram, the things that were moved in the house, the box left on my pillow, but in the end, there’s nothing they can really do.
Not until we know it’s her for sure.
This is exactly how I expected this to play out. She’s smart enough when it comes to the law not to cross over into that illegal category. She’s also stayed just invisible enough to fuck with me but not get fully caught.
“You ready?” Eli asks me, Mason strapped into his car seat, the diaper bag slung over Eli’s shoulder.
“Yeah, I guess,” I respond, looking around the house, wondering if this is the right decision.