AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

Found Hearts

Page 3

by Claire Raye

I also know if I asked him to stay, he would.

I unlock the front door and head inside, the screen slamming behind me and the cool ocean breeze following me in. I stick the beers in the fridge, grabbing a cold one that was already in there, before wandering out to the back deck.

Sinking into one of the chairs, I twist off the cap, propping my feet up on the railing as I take in the view. The blue of the ocean, the slowly darkening sky as the sun inches below the horizon. It’s pretty fucking awesome and not for the first time do I wonder how it is my mom could walk away from this place. From us.

Neither my dad nor I ever knew why she left. She never said anything to either of us, just disappeared one day, leaving only a note that said, “I’m sorry, I can’t.” I always wondered if it was because she wasn’t from here, that she never really settled into island life and she resented the fact that my dad and I had trapped her here.

It’s not like she was trapped though. Because my dad would have done anything for her, including leaving these islands if that’s what she truly wanted. But maybe it was just us that she never really wanted. Which is why neither of us has ever bothered looking for her to find out.

A knock at my front door breaks my trip down memory lane, and I stand, wondering who it could possibly be. All of my friends would either walk straight in or come around the back of the house.

When I reach the front door, the silhouette of a woman fills the screen. Pushing it open, I say, “Can I help you?”

She turns, a baby in her arms, and looks at me, her eyes doing a slow path from my face, down my torso, and back up again. “Eli.”

It’s said as a statement, not a question. “Yeah,” I respond. “And you are?”

She huffs out a laugh, but it’s more in annoyance rather than amusement. “Fits that you don’t remember,” she says, glancing down at the baby in her arms.

“Don’t remember what?” I ask.

She blows out a breath, glancing at the street before turning back to me. “We met on Oahu,” she now says. “You’d just graduated your fire academy thing. We were drinking. We hooked up.”

“Oh, yeah, okay,” I say, the memories of that night slowly coming back to me. “It’s Amber, no, Anna, right?”

“Amanda,” she says, rolling her eyes.

“Right, shit, sorry,” I say, knowing that was nearly a year ago now. “How are you?” It’s a stupid question, but I really don’t know what else to ask. Or why she’s here.

“Done,” she says, holding the baby out to me.

“What?” I ask, looking down at this kid that’s hovering between us. It’s asleep, oblivious to whatever this is.

“The kid’s yours,” she says.

“No,” I immediately say, shaking my head. “It can’t be, I always use a rubber.”

Amanda does that annoyed laugh thing again. “Yeah, well, I guess it broke, because nine months after I slept with you, this guy arrived.”

“What, you just expect me to believe that?” I ask, my heart pounding in my chest at just the possibility this might be true. It can’t be true. Surely.

“Do you remember having sex with me?” she asks.

I scrub my hand over my jaw, really looking at her as I wrack my brain for memories of that night, now so long ago. I’m not trying to be an asshole here, and she does look familiar, even if there have been quite a few since her.

Not gonna lie, I sleep with a lot of women. I like sex, but I don’t want a relationship, so I get it when I can. But one thing I’m good at, one thing I always make sure of, is that I’m always wearing a condom. Always.

“Yes?” I eventually say, the word sounding like a question.

She rolls her eyes. “Well, that’s something at least.”

I rub my hand over my head, gripping the back of my neck. “I’m sorry, I’m just really not sure what’s going on here,” I say, my world suddenly spinning on its axis as the possibility of what she’s saying sinks in.

“Let me break it down for you,” she says, stepping forward and all but throwing the kid into my arms. “We had sex, apparently the condom broke. I got pregnant, the kid’s yours and now I’m done.”

I take the baby she’s holding out to me, worried she’s gonna drop it with how much her arms are shaking. “What do you mean, you’re done?”

She steps back, relief on her face now she’s no longer holding the baby. “It means I never signed up for this. I don’t want a baby and I’m giving him to you.”