AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

Tell Me It’s Wrong

Page 73

by Katie Wismer

This is also her first time ever playing, and she’s still kicking my ass, so maybe I just suck.

Video games have never interested me much, but this game was one of the first things my parents bought when they took me in—I guess they figured, what fourteen-year-old boy wouldn’t be excited about an Xbox? Other than the occasional night with Leo and Liam, it usually collects dust in my closet.

I don’t know why it was the first thing to pop into my head after Chris left earlier. It was just something for us to do together that got her to stop staring at me. She’s always had that piercing gaze—even as kids—the kind that makes you feel like she can read your mind.

Barely a few seconds into the next game, my car plummets off the cliff again.

Jacks cackles and peers at my controller. “Are you even hitting the right buttons?”

I pull it closer to my chest so she can’t see—but I do double-check that I am, in fact, using the right ones. “Maybe I’m letting you win. Trying to make you feel welcome and everything.”

“Just remind me to never get in a car with you in real life.”

I scoff. “I am an excellent driver.”

Her eyebrows inch up as my car takes another dive. “I really see no evidence of that.”

We play another few rounds in silence, but I catch her smirks in my periphery every time I nosedive off another cliff.

I bite my lip to hold back from asking what she thinks about all the GED stuff she and Christine were talking about. She said she’d think about it, and I have a feeling if I keep asking, I’ll push her in the opposite direction.

“You could’ve called,” I say quietly.

“So could you,” she says, her voice clipped.

My eyes close for a second. I could’ve reached out after I left. Not knowing where she was placed after Joan and Bob was the excuse I’d told myself, but the truth is, I never looked back, never tried to find her. Not that it would’ve been easy—maybe even impossible—to track her down, but I’d never even tried.

I clear my throat. “I meant before coming all this way. What if the address you’d found was wrong? Or⁠—”

“I figured it’d be harder to tell me to get lost if you had to look me in the eye first.”

I set the controller on the couch between us. “I never would’ve told you to get lost.”

She stays focused on the screen as her car passes the finish line.

“I’m sorry,” I say, my voice coming out rough. “That I left. That I never checked back in.”

Her jaw hardens, and she nods.

“But I would really, really like to make it up to you now.”

That, finally, gets her to look over at me. “If what you actually want is for me to leave, I’d rather you tell me that than pretend.”

I shake my head and scoot closer to her on the couch. “I’m not pretending.”

“I know it’s weird,” she says as she turns back to the screen. “Me showing up here. I just…” Her shoulders slump on her exhale. “I didn’t know where else to go.”

“Weird?” I lean back and kick my feet up on the coffee table. I cast her a sideways smile, hoping to defuse the tension. “I would’ve been insulted if you’d gone anywhere else.”

She rolls her eyes, but smirks as she hands me my controller. “Come on. I’ll give you some pointers.”

Chapter Twenty-Nine

CHRISTINE

“Mommy, it’s on fire!” Casey shrieks and points at the stove.

I spin on my heel. The pancakes are, in fact, very smokey and undoubtedly burnt, but thankfully it’s not an actual fire. I quickly flip off the stove, remove the pan from the heat, and shove open the window over the sink.