AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

Tell Me It’s Wrong

Page 41

by Katie Wismer

“So what’ll it be? Orange juice, grapefruit, or cranberry?”

I expect them to fight me on it some more, but thankfully, they each ask for orange and let me walk away.

“Sorry,” Anna says out of the corner of her mouth as I pull a bottle of champagne from the fridge. “Should’ve warned you about them.”

“They’ve been here before?” I ask as I pop the cork.

She nods and grabs the orange juice for me. “Once last week. Got so drunk I thought I’d have to kick them out. Seemed like they were looking for someone.”

I pause and glance at them over my shoulder, my eyebrows pulling together. My mind jumps to Christine. I don’t know if that’s because I haven’t been able to get her off my mind in general, or because she’s the only other person I’ve seen in here that’s as out of place. I can’t see her being friends with them though. Maybe it’s presumptuous to think I know her that well, but from what I’ve seen of her personality, I can’t imagine her liking them.

I gather the drinks and can’t help but overhear their conversation as I walk over.

“…well I always thought it was especially callous of her, given the timing,” says the woman in the middle. “He was devastated after Lily’s death. Vulnerable. And she swooped right in.”

“Then managed to get herself pregnant to seal the deal,” agrees the tan one.

“Here you are.” I slide the drinks in front of them, but none of them acknowledge me.

“The nerve for her to stick around town too?” The third woman laughs, and the sound is ugly and hard. “Should’ve gone back to whatever backwater town she came from.”

I walk away before I have to hear any more. Unfortunately for me, the bar is quiet, and their voices carry.

“…and now poor Casey. That kid doesn’t stand a chance. He’ll probably turn out just like her…”

I freeze a few paces from Anna. Her eyes shoot to my face, and I stare back at her, the blood in my veins running hot. She cocks her head, a question in her eyes, and whatever she sees on my face is enough to spur her forward. She grabs my forearm and pulls me to the other side of the bar.

“Take a deep breath,” she murmurs.

I do. Then another.

It doesn’t help.

One of the women’s laughs cuts through the room again, and my jaw ticks.

Anna’s eyes flick between mine. “You know who they’re talking about.”

It isn’t a question.

She sighs when I don’t respond. “I can take over. Go take a break.”

I shake my head.

“Fletcher—”

I know she’s right. There is no good scenario here if I stay. What I really want to do is kick them the fuck out, but they’re the type to cause a big scene, threaten lawyers, and who knows what else. If I say anything, they’ll love it. Why is this random bartender jumping to her defense? It’ll give them a slew of new material to gossip about, and in the long run, that only hurts Christine more. I clench my hands into fists at my sides.

My phone buzzes in my apron pocket, and Anna nudges me toward the break room.

“Go. Take that. I’ll handle them. Please, Fletch. I’ll even spit in one of their drinks.”

She smirks as I meet her eyes, and I sigh. “Fine,” I grumble, then fish my phone out as I walk. I only make it a few paces before I pause at the sight of the name on the screen.

Chapter Eighteen

CHRISTINE

“Oh no. What happened to you?” Fletcher covers his mouth with his hand as I swing the door open, but there’s no mistaking the amusement in his eyes.