Page 6
He watched her from the edge of the mattress and ran a hand through his hair. “I like you, Jo. More than just four-a.m.-phone-calls like you.”
She jumped as she shimmied into her leggings and blew the hair out of her eyes. “Look, Jordan, it’s not that I don’t like you. We’ve had fun. I’m just not looking for anything more than that. I’m not doing relationships right now. Not with you—not with anyone.”
He locked his hands together in front of him, looked at the floor, and nodded slowly. It was probably one of the most pitiful things Jo had ever seen.
The smart thing to do would be to keep walking without another word. It was the coddled feelings that got them here in the first place. But still, seeing him like that, it reminded her of a version of herself she didn’t like to think about anymore.
She knelt down in front of him and placed her hands on his shoulders, shaking him until he finally looked at her. He pressed his lips together in a sad excuse for a smile. “Got it.”
“I’ll see you around, Jordan.” Then she leaned forward, kissed him lightly on the cheek, and left.
3
Freshman Year - August
Kayleigh rose onto her tiptoes as she strung the hot pink sheet across the room, tucking it between the lofted beds. A sea of blankets and pillows were already situated on the floor between them, the fort already fully stocked with three boxes of Lime-a-ritas and a family-sized bag of potato chips.
“Don’t knock the whole thing down!” Addie scolded as Liv climbed on Kayleigh’s desk to secure the other sheet across the back, this one a far less assaulting shade of lavender. Liv rolled her eyes as she hopped back down, her bunny slippers making a soft thud against the floor. Her curly black hair was pulled back in two braids and whipped around her shoulders as she collapsed onto the floor and eagerly grabbed a drink from the middle.
Jo tucked herself into the corner beside her bed and cracked open a can, watching as Kayleigh finished constructing their masterpiece. She’d brought down the string lights that usually hung above her bed and wound them around on the floor. They glowed against the bright sheets and cast a pink tint to everyone’s faces.
“Perfect!” Kayleigh ducked inside and plopped down across from Jo, her oversized T-shirt billowing out around her like a tent.
The entire room hummed with giddy energy as Liv thrust her Lime-a-rita into the middle of their circle. “I want to go first!” she announced. “Never have I ever…” She tilted her head to the side as she considered her next words, her grin slowly twisting into something mischievous. “Had sex with another woman.”
“Oh, real nice.” Addie rolled her eyes and threw back a sip of her drink.
Jo watched with wide eyes as Kayleigh also tipped her can back. When she caught Jo looking, Kayleigh shrugged. “Senior beach week.”
“My turn!” Addie swiveled her head to raise her eyebrows at Liv. “Never have I ever done cocaine.”
“I’m not ashamed of that,” Liv said matter-of-factly and took a long swig from her drink.
“Are the two of you just going to keep targeting each other all night?” Kayleigh demanded.
“By all means,” said Addie. “Give us a good one.”
Kayleigh shifted and crossed her legs, balancing her drink on her knee. “Never have I ever…” She narrowed her eyes a bit. “Gotten so drunk I’ve thrown up.”
Jo, Addie, and Liv all raised their cups and laughed.
“Cheers, ladies!” Liv sang, clanking her can against the others before eagerly gulping down another mouthful. When she was done, she crushed the can in her fist and tossed it vaguely in the direction of the trash can by the door. Her gaze shot from Addie’s face to the drink in her hand. “Looks like you’re already behind.”
“Maybe I’m just pacing myself,” said Addie.
Kayleigh nudged Jo with her knee. “Your turn.”
All three girls turned to her expectantly. Jo drummed her nails on her can, her mind suddenly blank. She didn’t have anything even remotely in the same league as the rest of them.
“Come on!” said Liv. “What’s the first thing that pops into your head?”
An image from senior year flashed into Jo’s mind—the one moment she’d been pointedly trying not to think about ever since it happened. But without it, her history was a slew of near misses and false starts—nothing worth oohing and ahhing over. Nothing that was really that interesting at all.
Addie leaned over and whispered something in Liv’s ear. They exchanged a knowing glance, and Liv covered her mouth with her hand to hide her giggle.
It was a look Jo was all too familiar with—the quick glances, the hushed voices that were oftentimes just loud enough to hear, and not by accident. To be honest, Addie and Liv weren’t even that good at it. The real skill came in the subtlety. The voices that crawled over your skin. The biting comments with just enough truth to them to burrow in. If Addie and Liv thought this little routine was having any effect, they were going to be sorely disappointed.
Jo pressed her lips together and tightened her fist around her drink. “Never have I ever kissed a teacher.”