Secret Baby For My Brother’s Best Friend
Page 49
"I hurt you first," he says, leaning back against the counter, giving me room.
"You did," I say, shaking my head slightly. "But I also heard everything through the worst parts of myself. Grayson's secret, Sienna's secret, Dad forgetting a little more every day, and under all of it the old fear that people decide what I can handle before they decide whether I deserve the truth."
His expression tightens, and he drops his eyes to the floor for a second. "I should have told you I suspected about Gray and Sienna."
"You think so?"
"I've thought about almost nothing else for two days," he says, rubbing a hand over the back of his neck. "I still believe it was his story to tell, not mine. But I should have told you I'd noticed something. That I didn't know the shape of it, only that there was history."
My throat tightens, and I set my tote carefully on a chair so I can stop twisting the strap between my fingers. "Why didn't you?" I ask, keeping my voice level.
"Because I was scared you'd ask questions I couldn't answer without betraying him," he says, holding my eyes. "And because I liked being the place you came when everything hurt. That's not noble. It's honest."
The honesty presses somewhere sore under my ribs.
"I liked being here," I admit, smoothing a palm down my dress. "That scared me too."
"Because of New York."
"Because of the timeline," I say, nodding with care. "Because every morning here stopped feeling like borrowing and started feeling like building, and I didn't know what to do with that."
His guarded tiredness softens into something almost painful. "I know," he says, and huffs a quiet laugh, looking toward the kitchen table. "Iris, I started planning groceries around what you like. I bought strawberry jelly at the diner because I didn't know where the store kept your kind, and then stood in my own kitchen like an idiot wondering if buying jelly for a woman counted as emotional escalation."
A laugh breaks out of me, shaky and relieved. "It absolutely counts as emotional escalation," I tell him.
"I was afraid of that." He pushes off the counter, then stops himself, asking permission with the restraint alone. "Can I come closer?"
I nod, and it feels bigger than a nod should.
He crosses the kitchen slowly, stopping close enough to see the shadows under his eyes and the pulse at his throat, far enough that I could still step back if I wanted to. I don't.
"I'm sorry I let you feel alone in something that had more pieces than you could see," he says, low now. "And sorry I got defensive. You were asking if I saw you, and I answered like you were attacking my loyalty to Gray."
"I was, a little," I say, wiping under one eye before the tear can fall. "But mostly I was asking if I mattered."
"You matter."
I look at his bare feet instead of his face. "I know."
"Do you?"
"I'm trying to," I say, and the bigger truth stays locked behind my teeth, because saying it now would turn his apology into a crisis and my apology into a confession, and there isn't room tonight for both.
He watches me a beat too long. "There's something else," he whispers.
My stomach drops. "There's always something else lately," I say, forcing my fingers to soften against my dress. "That doesn't mean I know how to talk about all of it yet."
He doesn't push. "Okay," he says, and pulls out the chair across from me, sitting with his hands folded on the table.
"I missed you," he says, simple, and it hits harder than any speech would have.
"I missed you too," I say, tracing a knot in the wood with one finger. "That made me angrier."
"I figured," he says, a small, tired smile pulling at his mouth.
"I wanted to stay mad because it made leaving feel righteous," I admit. "Then I talked to Sienna, and she said people don't usually need rules unless there's something they're scared will happen without them. Which was rude, considering her entire relationship history with my brother is a federal archive of avoidance."
He huffs a laugh, thumb tracing the table's edge. "She's not wrong."