AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

Secret Baby For My Brother’s Best Friend

Page 118

by Vivy Skys

"Dom." She sets her basket on the shelf and faces me while Winter interrogates her octopus a few feet away. "Come on. Everyone in this town has known you are in love with Iris since you moved here and started fixing her mother's old car for free while pretending it was about the invoice."

"That's not, " I start.

"Is it so crazy," she cuts in, gentler now, "that she's in love with you too? That she'd do something this hard, keep something this heavy, not because she wanted to hurt you, but because she wanted to protect the one thing you'd worked your whole life for? Is it so crazy that a woman would do anything for you, even something that made you hate her, even if she thought you'd never forgive her for it?"

I stand there in the middle of a furniture aisle with a shopping cart full of a stuffed octopus and a moon-shaped nightlight, and I don't have an answer ready, because the truth is I hadn't let myself think of it that way, not once, not in a whole week of turning the betrayal over and over in my hands looking for the sharpest edge.

"I hadn't thought of it like that," I admit, quiet.

Kendall looks down at Winter's toys on the rug. "I know. That's the problem with anger. It only lets you hold one shape of the story at a time."

"It still hurts," I tell her, my voice rougher than I mean it to come out. "Knowing that doesn't make it hurt less, Kendall."

"I know that too," she says, and reaches out to squeeze my arm once, brief and firm. "I'm not telling you to forgive her today. I'm just telling you it might not be as simple as the one version you've been carrying around all week."

Winter chooses that exact moment to fling herself against my leg, arms wrapping around my knee with the octopus still clutched in one fist, and I reach down and scoop her up without thinking, settling her against my hip the way I've watched Iris do several times now, like my body already knew the motion before the rest of me caught up.

"Daddy," she says, testing the word out loud, still a little unsure of it, still trying it on like a coat that might not fit yet.

Something in my chest cracks open at the sound of it, wide and unguarded, and I press a kiss to the top of her curls before she can see whatever's happening on my face.

"Yeah, baby," I say, my voice thick. "I'm right here."

She pats my cheek twice, satisfied with the answer, and goes back to narrating the octopus's various adventures against my shoulder, and Kendall watches the two of us with an expression I can't fully read, something between hope and caution, like she's not sure whether to say anything else or just let the moment sit.

"I'm going to go pay for this before she demands three more octopuses," Kendall says finally, gathering her basket, and I nod, following her toward the registers with Winter still babbling against my collarbone, her small hand finding the collar of my shirt and holding on like she's not planning on letting go anytime soon.

I think about what Kendall said the whole drive home, turning it over slowly while Winter falls asleep in her car seat, her head tipped sideways, the octopus still clutched against her chest.

Everyone knows you're still in love with Iris.

I don't argue with that part, not even privately, not even in the quiet of my own head where I've been lying to myself about plenty of things lately. What I can't get past is the second part, the part where loving someone and being lied to by them are supposed to sit peacefully in the same chest without one eventually crushing the other.

I glance at Winter in the rearview mirror, her curls a mess against the car seat strap, her mouth open slightly the way it does when she's fully out, and I think about every single day I missed of this, every nap, every bad joke, every octopus-related demand I never got to hear, and the anger comes back up hot and fast, exactly where it always comes back to.

But underneath it now, for the first time all week, there's something else sitting there too, something quieter and harder to name, and I don't examine it too closely on the drive home, because I'm not ready yet for what I might find if I do.

32

IRIS

"Tell me the truth," Sienna says, holding up two shades of blue paint swatches like she's asking a jury to decide the fate of her unborn child. "Is this seafoam, or does it look like I let a toddler pick out mucus for a nursery color?"

"It's seafoam," I answer, my voice muffled behind the paper mask I've had strapped to my face for the last hour, since I woke up this morning with a scratchy throat and decided the last thing Sienna needs nine months pregnant is whatever's brewing in my sinuses. "The mucus color is two shelves down, and it's called Harvest Wheat, which feels like false advertising."

"This is exactly why I need you here," Sienna says, tossing both swatches onto the growing pile on the changing table. "Grayson thinks every shade of blue looks identical. I showed him five paint chips last week and he pointed at the same one four times."

"He's a man who loves you," I say, taping another strip of rope trim along the window frame. "That's a documented cognitive deficiency."

Sienna laughs with one hand braced against the small of her back, her belly round beneath her shirt. The nursery is coming together around us, Aster's name spelled in driftwood letters on the wall, and I remember painting Winter's name alone at two in the morning.

"How's the Grammy sitting on the shelf treating you?" I ask, mostly to knock myself out of that particular memory before it can settle in too deep.

"Like an extremely heavy paperweight I'm not allowed to touch because Grayson's convinced it'll fall and kill someone," Sienna says, rolling her eyes. "He built it a little shrine on the mantel. Actual spotlight. I told him it's a music award, not the Ark of the Covenant, and he told me the lighting brings out the gold better."

"That tracks."

"It does," she agrees, easing herself into the glider with a groan. "God, I forgot how much this part sucked for you. I remembered the nausea and the waiting, but I did not understand how endless these last days feel until now."