Page 34
I find Indigo off the side aisle, in a little chapel barely bigger than a closet—a rack of votive candles, a marble saint, and shadows.
She's lighting a candle.
She doesn't believe in any of this, I know that, but she's lighting the candle carefully, with both hands cupped around the flame, and something in my chest goes sideways.
"Are you following me in a church now?" she says without turning around. "That's low even for you."
"I need two minutes."
"You need to go back to your pew. The one with a plaque."
"Olivia and I are not engaged…we're not even dating."
She turns around at that. The candlelight is doing things to her face that I have no business noticing. "Please, don't kid a kidder. There's a Page Six mention. There's my mother planning a wedding she won't shut up about, so—"
"There's an arrangement," I speak over her. "That's all there is. After the merger, we…yeah, we dated, but it didn't work out. I don't like her and…God knows what Olivia likes or wants."
Her lips curl. "Oh, she wants you."
"No, Indi. She wants the partnership…the Hale heir. If Kayden were the one inheriting the title, she'd marry him."
Her lips purse, and I see her shoulders go stiff. "I don't believe you."
"We dated, like I said, and we broke up months ago, but she insisted we pretend during the holidays, and I agreed because—" Because I'd already lost you, so what did it matter who I pretended to belong to. "Because it was easier than fighting it. It's theater. It's a press release with a dinner attached."
She stares at me. I watch her run the past few days back—the dinners, the toasts, every time she sat across a table believing I'd traded her for her sister—and I watch her land exactly where I knew she would.
"You let me think—" Her voice cracks, and she hates that, I can tell; she swallows it down. "For days…you let me feel like garbage for even looking at you—for feeling guilty when you looked at me."
"I know."
"Why?"
And here's where I could lie. I'm very good at it; I've had training. "Because as long as you believed it, you stayed on the other side of the room," I admit. "And I needed you on the other side of the room because every time you get within three feet of me, I can't keep my hands to myself." Or my heart.
"That's not—" she starts, and I don't know which of us moves.
I'd like to say it's her.
But it's probably me, in a chapel the size of a confessional, with the choir starting O Holy Night forty feet away and four hundred people and both our families on the other side of a stone wall.
Her hands fist in my coat and mine demolish her silken hair. She tastes like spiked eggnog and every bad decision I've ever wanted to make.
It's not a sweet kiss.
It's three years with the pin pulled out.
She shoves me back too quickly. Hard, both palms flat on my chest, breathing like she's been running.
"Your fiancée," she spits out, "is in the third pew."
"Fake girlfriend. Never proposed to her."
My tone makes her eyes narrow. "Oh, that makes it fine, then?" she rage whispers. "You don't get to hand me the truth on Christmas Eve in a church and expect it to be a gift, Xavier."
"It's not a gift. It's the truth."
"Wrapped in lies," she says sadly, her eyes burning with tears she's holding on to. I want them. I want everything she has to offer. "How can you live like this? How can you bear to be suffocated every day by both the truth and the lies?"