Page 15
“You said she was pretty.” Alan nearly sneers.
She thinks I’m pretty…
“But look at her,” he adds, killing the happiness in my chest.
“Alan,” Monica says reprovingly.
Why did I never notice that he excels at making me feel bad? Was I really so desperate that I just ignored all the red flags? Still, I let his reaction roll off and focus on Monica’s praise. I shouldn’t give unimportant people any power.
“Wow.” His eyes rake over me, from head to toe, then back up. He couldn’t make his contempt clearer.
I purse my lips. “Wow, indeed. I didn’t realize another name for Great Falls was Lake Tahoe.”
Alan flinches.
Steve and Monica frown. “What?”
“Nothing!” Alan quickly jumps in, then scowls as though irritated that he reacted with any hint of shame at all.
But Beck’s already put it together from the way his expression has gone almost dead with contempt. “You little shit.”
If Steve and Monica overheard it, they aren’t showing it and are quietly observing their sons.
“Right. I’m the little shit. I guess you learn something new every day. Latching on to my brother so soon after leaving me.” Alan says the last part just loud enough for my ears.
I give him a long look. I didn’t even know he had a brother—he never spoke of a sibling, just his “loving parents.” Not only that, he can’t possibly not be aware of why I broke up with him. The timing should’ve given him the hint. Or did he just never put it together?
But from the simmering resentment in his eyes, maybe not. He might’ve assumed I’d always be a doormat he could trample on for his amusement and some weird narcissistic gratification.
“Bae, this is absolutely gorgeous,” comes a semi-oblivious voice. A brunette appears from behind Alan. Her hair is artfully teased, and a green mini-dress and long brown boots look great on her very toned body. She lowers her phone. “Hi. I’m Chantelle.” Cocking her hip, she waves her well-manicured hand. She looks like a beauty pageant contestant dressed for the holidays. It wouldn’t surprise me if she started blowing kisses. “A.k.a. Alan’s girlfriend.” She gives a cute little shrug and smiles.
I look down at my own simple clothes, then note her perfect makeup juxtaposed against my nearly bare face. Guess she’s the kind of girl he really wanted. She’s probably the kind to pay for things without checking the price, while I search for coupons.
“Hello. I’m Monica, and this is Steve,” Monica says, all smooth graciousness, but none of the warmth from earlier shows in her expression. “What a delight it is to have so many people for Christmas.”
“Yes.” Steve’s smile doesn’t reach his assessing eyes. “Why don’t you all sit down and enjoy some snacks before dinner?”
I move to sit next to Beck, while Alan and Chantelle take a loveseat to Steve and Monica’s right. It’s so small, Chantelle’s practically sitting on Alan’s lap, but he doesn’t seem to care. Monica and Steve exchange a quick glance, then act like they haven’t noticed anything.
“Anyway, Willow, you can take your things to the riverside suite later,” Monica says, as though to unwind the tension.
Alan closes his eyes for a moment. “No. I want that one for Chantelle.”
Monica lets out an awkward laugh. “There’s no reason to argue over guest bedrooms. We have plenty.”
I nibble on a cookie and sip the eggnog. Not sure exactly what the deal is with the suite Alan’s so upset about.
“Then where’s Chantelle going to stay?” he says.
“The garden suite. It’s closer to your room anyway,” Monica explains.
“What? No! Why are you trying to put me down in front of my girlfriend? You know that side is the shittier side, and I just put up with it because I’m younger. Do you think she’s so special?”
“Alan, it just makes sense to divide it like that,” Monica says. “Not everyone can be in the same suite.”
Alan opens his mouth, but Chantelle lowers her phone after tapping the screen a few times. “What are we talking about?”
“The guest room,” Alan says. “Why should a piece of discarded trash like her take the best one?” He gestures at me.