AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

The No-Judgment Zone

Page 68

by Ellie K. Wilde

“Well, if you were to find yourself a better match in the process…”

“I wouldn’t,” I say dismissively. “This is going to require some major trickery. He saw me coming from a mile away when I tried to get him to sleep with me. Convincing him to date me… I’m going to have to pull out all the stops. Use every bit of game I have.”

“What are you thinking?”

I move my ponytail off my shoulder, pondering hard. “The jealousy thing is definitely good, but it’s not enough. He knows about my past and isn’t fazed by it at all. I already swore I’d stop trying to seduce him into sex, so that’s out.” I nibble on my thumb, staring at Jude without really seeing her. There are numbers flashing across my sightline, and I’m scrambling to catch them all, do the math. “I need to take this all the way somehow. I need to make him fall in love with me. In a head over heels, there’s no other option but to be with me sort of way.”

“And how do you do that?”

Immediately, the question takes the wind out of my sails. They flutter uselessly around me.

“I… I don’t know. I can’t remember the last time I was shooting for love,” I say, deflating. “I mean, has anyone loved me? Even with my ex, I can’t be sure. Would he have cheated if he loved me?”

The realization is a punch in the gut. Has… Has Ronnie been right this whole time?

Am I too much?

Not serious enough? Too promiscuous? Do I really look like a sexed-up pony?

I pinch a strand of hair from my ponytail, staring at the pink lock.

“Jenna,” Theo starts. His shoulders have capsized, watching me spiral. “Don’t do that to yourself.”

“I love you,” Jude says softly, taking my hand.

“Right. Right.” I nod. There are people who like me this way. There are. I release the breath I’ve been holding and shake out my shoulders. “Whew. Okay, that got dark for a second.” I jerk my head in Theo’s direction. “How’d you get this one so obsessed with you?”

“Honestly, I was kind of short with him at the start…”

I hum appreciatively. “Playing hard to get. That’s certainly an option.”

Theo drags a hand down his face, muttering something that sounds a whole lot like for fuck’s sake, these two.

“Got anything to add there, sweetums?”

Theo turns a pair of highly exasperated eyes in my direction. “I won’t entertain this bullshit. I’m telling you that you don’t need to trick him into anything because he’s already into you.”

“Okay, let’s pretend for a second that’s true. How do I get him to act on being into me? And don’t tell me to tell him how I feel. I could lay it all out for him tonight and he’d give me a very polite thank you, lock himself in his room and refuse to come out until I leave in September, because he’s too nice to kick me out. You know it’s true.”

I’ve got him there. He crosses his arms and stares at the ground.

I stand from the desk, shaking my hair out of its ponytail and massaging my temples. Suddenly I have a pounding headache. I’ve never had a problem getting my way with a man. Then again, I’ve never had an opponent like Finn.

This new plan, the one where I try to win him over, decide he wants to be with me despite the commitment issues… It’ll be the hardest battle I’ve ever fought.

He’s worth it. He makes me feel like I’m worth it, too.

But where do I start?

How do I talk Finn Palmer into falling in love with me?

“Thanks guys,” I say wryly. “Came here for answers and left with even more questions. You two really are terrible matchmakers.”

“Oh, I know!” Jude says brightly, jumping to her feet and gathering Theo’s things off the desk. “Why don’t we all go out for drinks Friday night? We can watch you in action and suss him out for you. Can you let Finn off the clock?”

“We can work that out,” Theo says.

He takes his laptop from her and shoves his phone in the back pocket of his jeans. He drops a gentle hand on my shoulder when I make for the door behind Jude. “Hey. I know… I’ve lived through how hard it is, wanting someone who doesn’t seem to want you back. I get how soul crushing it can get. But I want to make sure that you’re sure—the all-in kind of sure, before jumping into anything with Finn. He’s got an armor like no other, and I’ve heard of what happens when he takes a hit without it on. It’s not pretty. Don’t let him drop his guard unless you mean it.”