Page 83
Jenna blows me a kiss over her shoulder, and it’s clear whatever’s about to happen, it’s been agreed upon prior. I’m not sure I like it, these two conspiring against me.
“If this is about getting into Jenna’s good graces, I don’t think you need my help,” I tell him, draining the rest of my drink. “Though I will take the undying gratitude. I told you this was the perfect set up. I don’t get why you never called her.”
“I have my reasons,” he says lightly, crossing his arms and propping them on the table between us. “But this conversation is about you, Guinea Pig. Are you ever gonna put that poor guy out of his misery?”
I roll my eyes. “Are you seriously asking me whether I’m going to sleep with your friend?”
Finn’s face screws up in confusion. “No? Why would you think… Oh, hell,” he says suddenly, dragging a hand down his face. “This is worse than I thought. And that’s saying something considering what I’ve already witnessed.”
“What are you talking about?”
Finn shakes his head, exasperated. “He’s not trying to fuck you – well, he probably is, but it’s not about that.” He takes in my confusion. “Christ, you’re as bad as he is, aren’t you? Look, he’s a mess over you. I’ve never seen him stumble his way around a woman like this in all the years I’ve known him.”
Stumble? Whatever Finn sees, I don’t. Flirting between Theo and me comes easy, and it’s becoming damn near impossible to keep my hands off him.
“Shit, he’s coming back. I’m gonna go see if Jenna needs a hand, give you a couple minutes alone,” Finn says, with a glance over my shoulder. “But listen, if you still need a nudge in the right direction… I was a culinary school dropout. Did he tell you that? I had a rough go of it for a while and school didn’t cut it for me. But he took me on, anyway. Hired me, taught me just about everything I know. He can be moody as anything but he’s as good a guy as they come. Give him a shot.”
He flashes me a smile as he takes in the flush spreading on my face. It must be bad, because Theo eyes Finn’s retreating figure suspiciously when he drops into his seat.
He hesitates around a word, then shakes his head. “You know, what? Don’t tell me. I don’t want to kill a man tonight.”
“Don’t worry,” I laugh. “He talks very highly of you.”
Theo shrugs. “He’s a good guy. Despite the act he puts on whenever a woman over the age of twenty enters the room.”
I watch him fiddle with a bar napkin, thinking back to Finn’s words. Theo’s always been abundantly clear about his attraction to me. But the idea that there could be something more to how he feels… My relief is so acute I could almost laugh, if it didn’t make my inside wring out in terror.
I don’t want a relationship. There’s too much risk involved, too much riding on another person to keep from getting hurt.
And yet –
“What can I get ya?”
A server appears beside us and I almost jump out of my skin. Suddenly, the din of the bar is unbearable. I crave a moment alone with him. To make sense of where his head is, and what I want to do about these feelings for him.
Theo nods to me. “Another?”
“I…” I glance over my shoulder, seeing Jenna make her way back through the crowd with Finn at her heels. “Actually, I think I’m going to head out.”
Theo’s face falls. But he regroups quickly and gives me a tight smile. I slide my elbow an inch to the right, closing the gap between our arms. “Walk me home?”
His lackluster smile falls away. And the initial surprise melts into a look that can only be described as pure delight as he helps me up. “Yeah. Yes. I’ll go pay off our tabs.”
Jenna appears at my shoulder, face lit up in excitement. “Juju, this guy is so smitten with you, I could scream. You left the table earlier and I swear he looked like a lost puppy. He got all fidgety like he couldn’t figure out what to do with himself.”
I’m melting. Melting into a puddle, right here in the middle of this bar.
“We’re going to head out. Do you want to come?”
“Sorry, no,” Finn cuts in, throwing an arm over Jenna’s shoulders. “Our work is done. You need to take it from here, Guinea Pig.”
“Go,” agrees Jenna. “Have fun. And don’t overthink it, okay?” She nudges me towards where Theo now waits by the door.
It’s a warm night. And as we take off down the busy sidewalk, going at such a leisurely pace you’d think we weren’t going anywhere at all, I’m grateful I talked myself out of the heels I briefly debated before slipping on a pair of sandals.
“Hey, so are you hungry?” Theo asks after a few minutes of silence. “There’s a pizza place kind of near your apartment that does the best slices in the city, hands down. And… we could go down to the waterfront to eat? If you want. It’ll probably add another twenty minutes to the walk, but I –”
He’s rambling. Hearing him sound so unsure of himself is a tidal wave of pain to my chest. Am I really so cold he’d still think I’d say no to spending time with him? When the reality is that I crave his company almost constantly.