Page 107
“What?” I whisper.
“Only one.” He shifts a little closer to me on the bed. “I don’t know why I did it, but something made me ask for it. I might not have been in my right mind, but I wanted it, and the only thing I regret is that I don’t remember it at all.” He shoots me a little smirk that makes my stomach wobble. “It would be nice to have the memories to go along with the video.”
I stare at him for way longer than I should as I try to process everything he just said.
“But you kept saying you’d tell people what I did to you,” I whisper, finally breaking the silence that’s fallen over us.
He purses his lips, but he doesn’t look frustrated or angry. He looks…concerned? No, that can’t be right.
“That was just sex talk. I’d never out you like that. And as far as I’m concerned, everything that happened between us was consensual, so there’s nothing to tell.” He gently runs the backs of his fingers over my cheek. “Did you think I was seriously blackmailing you into fucking around with me?”
I shiver under his gentle touch. “At first,” I admit.
“So you thought that’s why I kept coming back to you this entire time?”
I shrug and look back down at my comforter. “I mean, why else would you want to hook up with me when you could have anyone you wanted?”
“Babe, look at me.”
I lift my gaze to his. The endearment makes something deep inside me ache.
He’s been calling me that a lot for the past couple of weeks, and every time it makes me wish that he meant it and that I really was special to him.
“I was never going to blackmail you. It was just part of our sex talk. And didn’t you notice that I stopped saying that stuff weeks ago?”
That makes me pause.
He’s right. He stopped making any references to telling people about the night of the Halloween party within the first week. He kept up the talk about what people would think if they saw us together, but there was never a threat of him telling anyone, just what would happen if someone walked in on us.
“So, we’ve been even pretty much this whole time?” I ask stupidly.
He runs his fingers over my cheek again. “I should have said something instead of assuming you knew things had changed between us.” He drags his thumb over my bottom lip in a smooth slide that’s more tender than teasing. “That’s on me, but I thought it was obvious when I started sending you pics. This whole thing started because of a video, and I sent you pics of me so you’d have something on me too.”
“What?” I whisper.
“And I gave you my real number.”
“Your real number?” I ask, too stunned to be more articulate.
“Yeah.” He presses his thumb against my lip. “The only people who have that number are my family and the friends who matter.”
“But you said it was to keep work and nudes separate.”
He sighs and drops his hand. “It wasn’t just to keep things separate. I should have been clearer about that too.”
My stomach flip-flops. “But what about the others?”
“There are no others,” he says seriously.
“There have to be,” I insist, my chest tightening as hurt fills me.
“There aren’t.”
“But—”
He pulls his phone out of his pocket and unlocks it. “Here,” he says, extending it toward me.
I stare at it like I’ve never seen a phone before.