AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

The Earl’s Christmas Letter

Page 29

by Bronwen Evans

Beth,

I am told that men who have watched love go wrong are careful with their words. Your mother told me so last night at Kendall Park’s expense, or rather at mine, and she was right, as she is about most things. I have been careful with my words my whole life. I have been careful with them with you most of all. And you have had nothing from me but carefulness, and one very ill-chosen word on the ice, and I find this morning that I cannot bear it a moment longer.

So I am writing to you, because it seems that in this matter it is letters that tell the truth.

I love you. I have loved you since the summer you were sixteen and threw a book at Richard’s head for laughing at Mr Wordsworth, and missed, and hit me. I did not know it was love then. I thought it was the book. I have spent every year since telling myself it was something else: admiration, friendship, the natural regard of an old acquaintance, lust, God forgive me, and in my worst moments, good sense. It was none of those things. It was you.

When I said “inevitable” I did not mean that you were bound to come to me. I meant that I was bound to love you, whatever you did. That I had no more choice in the matter than the snow has in falling. I meant it as a confession, and I said it like a threat, and I have been sorry for it every hour since.

I held your letter like a hostage. I know that now. I tell myself I would have given it back without terms, and I believe I would have, but I cannot prove it, because it was taken from me before I could. So I cannot give you that gift. I find I have only one thing left to give you, and it is the only thing you ever asked me for.

The choice.

If you do not want me, Beth, you need do nothing at all. Burn this, and I will come to dinner as your mother asked, and I will be your friend and Richard’s friend and I will never ask you again. You will never have to refuse me. I will not make you weigh me and find me wanting in your mother’s drawing room. I will simply be there, as I have always been, and you will never hear another word of this from me as long as I live.

But if you do want me, I am at home. I have been at home since six o’clock, standing at my study window like a fool, and I will stand there all morning.

I no longer care whom that letter was written to. I gave up hoping it was not meant for any other man. I only hope that your heart is not.

Happy Christmas, my love.

James

Beth read it twice. The second time she could not see the words for tears.

Then she was across the room and pulling open the press, dragging out the first warm gown her hands found, which was the green, and struggling into it with no maid and no patience and her fingers all thumbs on the buttons. She found her half-boots. She found her cloak. She did not find her bonnet and did not look for it.

She was halfway down the stairs when a voice spoke from the landing above.

“Bethany.”

She froze, one hand on the banister.

Her mother stood at the top of the stairs in her dressing gown, a candle in one hand and her grey hair in a long plait over her shoulder. She looked down at her daughter, at the cloak and the boots and the letter crushed in one gloved fist, with no surprise whatsoever.

“Mama, I⁠—”

“Take Molly,” her mother said. “She is already in the kitchen with her cloak on. I took the liberty. And Bethany.” The faintest of smiles. “Do try to be home in time for church.”

The snow on Grosvenor Square was as untouched as the snow on her own. Beth’s boots were the first to mark it. She left a trail of small, hurrying prints from the hackney all the way to his door, with Molly’s following, and she thought she had never seen anything so lovely as that crooked line of footprints across all that white.

The knocker was just as cold and heavy under her glove as it had been on the first of December.

It was the same footman. He opened the door, and his eyes widened, and then, to her astonishment, he smiled.

“His lordship is in his study, Lady Beth. You need not wait in the blue parlour.”

“I know the way,” Beth said, and went.

He was standing at the window, exactly as he had been that first afternoon. Tall and dark against the white glare of the square, his shoulders very straight, his hands clasped behind his back. He had not heard the knocker. He had been looking at the snow, and he did not turn until the door clicked shut behind her.

Then he did turn, and saw her, and his whole face changed.

She had thought him handsome for years. She had never seen him look like this. As though every careful wall he had ever built had come down at once and there was nothing left but a man looking at the one thing in the world he wanted.

“You came,” he said. His voice was barely there.

“You said you would be at the window.”