AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

The Earl’s Christmas Redemption

Page 7

by Christina Diane

“So you ran,” she snapped, her voice fierce and unyielding. “You used your grief as an excuse and ran away. When your sister needed you. When I needed you.” She saw the impact of her words on him, saw how each one seemed to cut deeper than the last. But if she was cruel, it was only because she was also scarred by what he’d done. Her grip tightened around the snowball.

He flinched and released a deep sigh. The dark shadows beneath his eyes seemed more pronounced in the harsh winter light. “I couldn’t stay. The pain... It was unbearable.” His voice broke again, and he stopped, looking down at the snow beneath their feet.

“I know that pain well,” she spat, resisting the unwelcome flash of empathy.

“Yes,” he said, struggling to hold her gaze. “I suppose you must.”

“Is that all you have to say?” She looked at him, daring him—begging him—to say something that might resolve the past, that might give her some sense of comfort. That was folly. There was nothing that could justify what he’d done.

“I’m sorry,” he said at last. His voice was barely a whisper, but there was a conviction in it that echoed around them like a vow. “More than you can ever know.”

Maddie stood, suspended in that moment, finally hearing the apology she believed she had wanted from him for so long. And yet, it didn’t bring her the comfort she thought it would. Just more sadness. As if she’d lost him all over again. The pain of it welled up inside her, and before she could reconsider, she drew back her arm and hurled the snowball directly at his chest.

It struck him with a soft thud, exploding into a powder that clung to his dark coat. For a moment, he looked completely stunned, blinking down at the mess. Then, impossibly, the corner of his mouth twitched upward. Not quite a smile, but something close to it—the first real emotion she’d seen from him since their encounter began.

“I suppose I deserved that,” he said, brushing the snow from his coat, flashing her a small grin. A fleeting light sparked in his eyes—something reminiscent of the old John, the one who never failed to make her laugh.

Maddie wasn’t sure whether to be infuriated that he’d taken her assault so calmly or oddly satisfied that she’d broken through his careful composure. Before she could decide, he bent down and scooped up a handful of snow himself.

“You wouldn’t dare,” she warned, taking a step back.

His eyes met hers, and for a moment the years melted away. “I wouldn’t?” He carefully shaped the snow, his hands moving with deliberate intent as he packed it into a perfect sphere.

She backed away further, suddenly uncertain. This was not how she had imagined their confrontation would go. She had expected anger, denial, perhaps even cold indifference. Not this strange, charged moment that hovered between past and present. But she liked it.

John’s gaze held hers, and something shifted in his expression—a flash of the mischievous boy he’d once been, before grief and whatever else had dimmed his light. “For what it’s worth,” he said, weighing the snowball in his hand, “I deserve far worse than this.”

Before she could respond, he drew back his arm and launched the snowball. She had only a second to react, turning slightly so that it struck her shoulder instead of her chest. The impact was surprisingly gentle—he’d clearly held back—but it was enough to send a shock through her system.

“You—” Maddie sputtered, brushing snow from her cloak. “How dare you!”

But instead of anger, she felt something else entirely—a surge of adrenaline, a rush of something almost like exhilaration. Without thinking, she bent down and gathered more snow, packing it quickly.

John’s eyes widened in surprise. “Maddie—”

She hurled the second snowball with more force than the first, and it caught him squarely in the chest. This time, he laughed—a rusty, uncertain sound, as if his voice had forgotten how. It tugged at all of her emotions.

For a heartbeat, they stared at each other, suspended between their painful past and this unexpected moment. Then John crouched down, gathering more snow.

“This means war, Lady Madeline,” he said, and for an instant, she saw a glimpse of the man she had once loved—vibrant, playful, alive.

She had no time to dwell on it as she darted behind the fountain, gathering ammunition. “You’re outmatched, my lord,” she called back, surprising herself with the lightness in her voice.

John’s snowball sailed over the fountain, missing her by inches. “My aim was always superior to yours, if you recall.”

“And your memory was always selective,” she retorted, launching a volley of her own. It caught him on the arm as he twisted away.

They circled the fountain, trading snowballs and barbs that grew less cutting with each exchange. Maddie felt her anger shifting into something else—not forgiveness, not yet, but perhaps the faint possibility that they might someday speak without it hurting quite so much.

John ducked behind a hedge, and Maddie crept forward, snowball at the ready. When she reached the corner, he was gone. She turned, scanning the garden—and felt a soft impact against her back.

“Ambush,” he called from behind her, and she whirled to find him grinning. It was a pale shadow of his former smile, but it reached his eyes for the first time since she’d seen him again.

“Coward,” she shot back, but there was no venom in it. She bent to gather more snow, but as she straightened, she saw his expression change. The light faded from his eyes, and his shoulders seemed to slump again beneath that invisible weight. Just as quickly as it had appeared, the moment of lightness was gone.

“Yes,” he said quietly, the playfulness evaporating like mist. “I am.”

The sudden shift in his demeanor startled her. She lowered her arm, allowing the snowball to fall from her hand. “John—”