The Earl’s Christmas Redemption
Page 24
Once he had moved out of earshot, Rosina took Maddie’s arm and guided her toward a stone bench partially sheltered by an evergreen hedge. After brushing away the snow, she gestured for Maddie to sit.
“I’m thankful I spotted you from the window. Running away is rarely the solution,” Rosina began, staring at her intensely. “You should know so better than anyone after what you’ve suffered.”
Maddie stiffened. “I’m not running away. I’m simply... removing myself from an untenable situation.”
“As someone who cares for you, I can’t help but wonder if you’re making a decision you’ll come to regret.”
“The only decision I regret is coming to this house party,” Maddie countered, her voice sharp with emotion. “If I’d known he would be here—”
Rosina pinched the bridge of her nose. “My brother is still very much in love with you, Maddie. And I don’t believe he would ever depart from you again, if you gave him a chance.”
The words struck Maddie like a physical blow. She looked away, unwilling to let the Duchess see how deeply they affected her. “If that were true, he has a strange way of showing it.”
“Men often do.” Rosina’s laugh was soft, tinged with exasperation. “Particularly men like John, who believe they must bear every burden alone. Who struggle with things they can’t explain.”
“And I’m supposed to believe he’s changed? That he’s learned from the error of his ways and I can magically trust him again?”
“Not changed, perhaps,” Rosina said thoughtfully. “Rather, returned to himself.”
Maddie’s brow furrowed. “I don’t understand.”
The Duchess sighed, smoothing an invisible wrinkle from her skirt. “The man you fell in love with. That is the real John. And I see glimmers of him returning to us. I truly believe it is because of you. For you.”
Maddie stared at Rosina, unable to fully absorb her words. “You speak as if he’s been ill.”
“Not in body,” Rosina replied carefully, “but in mind, and spirit. That illness can be far more damaging than a physical ailment. When he left you, he left himself behind as well.”
A bitter laugh escaped Maddie’s lips. “How convenient. And I’m to forgive everything because he has suffered too?”
“No.” Rosina’s voice was firm. “That is for you to decide. But I ask you to consider if you would forgive him if he had been physically ill? If you’d give him sympathy and love. Illness of the mind is much the same, if not worse. We don’t speak about persistent melancholy because of the stigma associated with it, but it’s very real and my brother did the best he could. I see that now. The reasoning might not be good enough for you, and that is fair. But if you love him, truly love him, I urge you to give what I’ve said some thought.”
Maddie’s chest tightened. How dare Rosina suggest something as simple as melancholy could excuse John’s abandonment? And yet... there had been signs, hadn’t there? The darkness that sometimes shadowed his eyes even in their happiest moments. The way he would occasionally withdraw into himself, becoming distant for a brief period before returning to her with renewed passion. It was as if a veil had been lifted, and she saw him differently than she ever had before.
She recalled a particular night, shortly before Ryan’s illness, when she’d found John standing alone on a balcony during a ball, his expression so desolate it had frightened her. When she’d questioned him later, he’d dismissed it as exhaustion, but now she wondered if it had been something more—something he hadn’t known how to name or share. Or that he had felt he couldn’t show any hint of weakness.
“Even if what you say is true,” Maddie said, needing more time to process, “it doesn’t change what happened. He left me without a word. Not a letter, not a message. Nothing.”
“I know.” Rosina’s eyes held genuine regret. “And I would never suggest that his pain negates yours. Only that perhaps there is more to understand than what he’s allowed you to see.”
“And how do you know this?” Maddie asked.
“Because I’ve learned a thing or two about trauma. My own, as well as my husband’s. It’s not susceptible to mere logic. The more I’ve watched my brother these few days and how he’s adapted to being back, the more I understand. I wish I had realized sooner what had driven him away.” Rosina released a deep sigh. “You weren’t the only one he abandoned, Maddie. But he’s my brother, so of course I shall forgive him. You aren’t required to feel such an obligation. Just know that I’ve seen how he looks at you still.”
Maddie looked toward where Louis waited by the carriage, his expression patient and understanding even from a distance. He had been her rock, her constant. But was that the right reason to bind herself to him? She’d always said from the time she was a girl that she would marry for love.
“I don’t know what to do,” Maddie admitted quietly.
“Stay,” Rosina urged gently. “At least stay for Christmas. Give yourself your time to think this through. Even if you wish to hide in your chamber. I shall cover for you.”
Something in Maddie’s heart told her to stay. All that Rosina had shared caused her mind to race.
Mental illness. Depression. The words settled heavily in Maddie’s mind. She had heard whispers of such afflictions, of course, but they were spoken of in hushed tones, if at all. Gentlemen of their society simply didn’t succumb to such weaknesses—or rather, no one could be permitted to acknowledge them. Just look at their king.
After a long moment, Maddie nodded slowly. “Very well.”
Relief crossed Rosina’s face. “Thank you.” She rose from the bench, extending her hand to help Maddie up. “Now, we must tell Lord Ashworth to cancel his carriage.”
As they walked back toward the waiting carriage, Maddie felt something shift within her. Not forgiveness, but perhaps the first tenuous step toward understanding.