AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

The Earl’s Christmas Redemption

Page 17

by Christina Diane

“I see,” he said, his voice strained. He took to pacing before her. “So you have affection for him, then?”

“He’s been my closest friend since we were children.”

“Is that all he is to you?” John’s voice had dropped to a dangerous whisper, the kind that made the fine hairs on Maddie’s arms stand on end.

“I don’t owe you explanations,” she replied, wrapping her arms around herself, suddenly aware of how thin her night rail and dressing gown were in the chilly library. “You forfeited that right when you walked away.”

John’s eyes darkened as they traveled from her face down to where her arms crossed her body. “You’re right,” he conceded, his voice raw. “I have no claim on you. Not anymore.”

The sadness in his voice made something twist painfully in Maddie’s chest. At one time, she had wanted him to hurt as she had hurt, but now, faced with his pain, she found no satisfaction in it.

“He wishes to marry me,” Maddie blurted, immediately regretting the words. Why had she told him that? What purpose could it serve except to hurt them both?

The words hung in the air between them, as John went completely still. Only his eyes betrayed him—a flash of something so primal and wounded that Maddie had to look away.

“And will you accept him?” John asked, his voice unnaturally controlled.

Maddie’s heart thundered in her chest. She hadn’t a clue what to do.

“I haven’t given him an answer,” she admitted softly, the fight draining from her.

John exhaled, a sound caught between relief and anguish. “Why not?”

“Because I—” She faltered, unable to articulate the tangled mess of feelings inside her. “I don’t love him. Not in that way.”

Everything in her told her to run. To remove herself from saying anything else that would only make matters worse.

As if sensing her distress, John reached for her hand before she could retreat, his warm fingers enclosing hers. The touch sent a jolt through her body, awakening sensations she had tried desperately to forget.

“And do you believe you could find love again?” he asked, his voice low and hoarse.

Maddie looked down at their joined hands, a feeling that was familiar and also foreign. How many times had she dreamed of his touch during those first lonely months after he’d left?

“I don’t know,” she whispered truthfully. “I want what you and I...”

Her gaze met his, and the intensity she found there stole her breath. His eyes bore into hers with such naked longing that she couldn’t bear it. She felt exposed, as if he could see past her carefully constructed defenses to the part of her that had never stopped loving him.

The realization struck her with the force of a physical blow. She still loved him. She hated him, and she loved him. It was the most maddening feeling, but her heart couldn’t let him go.

The knowledge terrified her.

Ripping her hand from his, she sprinted away. Hurrying from the room before she did something she would surely regret, like falling into his arms and begging him never to leave her again. Women around the world would call her a fool.

Instead, she fled down the darkened halls, not stopping until she reached her chamber.

As she closed the door behind her, leaning against it with her heart pounding, she realized she was still clutching the book she’d taken from the library.

Maddie sank to the floor, the book clutched to her chest, and let the tears flow. She cried for what had been lost, for what might have been, and for what pain would ensue if she allowed herself to imagine what could be.

Chapter 7

John

After a fitful night of sleep and barely speaking a word the following morning at breakfast, John watched from the window as Maddie moved through the garden path, her chestnut hair gleaming in the winter sunlight, her gloved hand resting far too affectionately on Ashworth’s arm. The sight sent a knife of pure agony twisting in his gut.

He shouldn’t feel this way—shouldn’t care that she was smiling up at that proper, dull buffoon. Well, Ashworth wasn’t a buffoon. He was actually a really kind, amiable sort, but that did little to make his heart feel any better. Every time he watched her smile and then cover her mouth with laughter felt like she was driving another nail into the coffin of what hope he held onto that things might be salvageable between them.

Last night’s conversation echoed in his mind. The memory of her pained expression and her admission that she’d been with the man made his throat tighten. He leaned against the frost-rimed window, watching them through the glass as they continued on their stroll. Even now, knowing it made him only slightly better than a stalker, and he was only torturing himself. He still couldn’t tear his eyes away from her.