Page 29
I didn’t reply as I drafted an email to Maren and attached the file, along with the photos Audrey had given me of Nate and Alex in their younger days.
Everything had poured out of me last night and into the early morning hours, the need to get all the words in my head onto my computer screen almost visceral.
“Is something wrong, Tay?”
“No. Just wanted to get this done,” I said, reading over my email one last time before I finally hit send. I’d had maybe two hours of sleep last night, but the adrenaline still coursing through me had me wide awake.
I sent the article to Nate even though he insisted he didn’t need to see it. I shot him a quick text to look if he wanted to get a preview.
“Okay, I’m done.” I blew out a long breath and stuffed my computer back into my bag and under the chair. “Push me one of those floats.”
“This big donut is pretty comfy. Let’s get real ones later,” Caitlin said, reaching for a cupcake float and almost tipping over as she shoved it toward me.
“We have some in the kitchen. If Gabby didn’t eat the last three last night.” I plopped onto the float, steadying myself as I fought the urge to hop out and check the article one last time even though I’d handed it in.
“Didn’t your sister write an article about Silas too? That’s how they met, right?”
“No, they’d met before. They…met for dinner and didn’t think they’d see each other again until the Bats became her client.”
Rachel had told me the real story after she’d had Gabby. She’d been loopy on pain meds after an emergency C-section and had told me through sobs how lucky she was because the stranger she’d spent a random night with had become the love of her life and father of her babies.
I wasn’t sure if she remembered what she’d told me after her recovery, but I’d never asked for additional details. That story was between them, and I’d never tell what I knew, even to Caitlin.
“I thought so. Interesting,” she said, twisting her auburn hair into a bun.
“Interesting?”
“Sure. Maybe this could be you.” She swept her gaze over our huge yard and deck. “Relaxing in your own Brooklyn mansion with your beautiful baseball babies.”
“No,” I said, quick enough for Caitlin to still in the water.
“Something happened, didn’t it?” Her head popped up when she let out a gasp. “You finally kissed Nate. Oh God, what was it like? He’s so smooth and limber on the field.” She fell back on the float, kicking her feet in the water. “I bet his tongue could do amazing things—”
“I didn’t kiss Nate. It just…got a little weird.”
“Weird?” She drifted over to me, bumping the edge of my float with hers. “Weird, how?”
“I thought he was going to kiss me a couple of times, but I’m sure it was just in my head. He’s going through a rough time, and he’s in his feelings about it.”
“Yeah, I’m going to need more information than that.” She paddled in front of me. “How could a PR crisis caused by his massive cock get him in his feelings enough to almost kiss you?”
“He’s…vulnerable. We were both a little tense on the way up to his mother’s house yesterday. I’m not sure if I’m the magical cure for all this chaos, and I’m afraid whatever I do isn’t going to work. He picked up on it and told me that he’d been nervous for me when I’d had to interview Tino because he’d wanted the best for me too.”
“I see. That’s it?” She lifted her sunglasses to squint at me.
“And when I told him I didn’t like being in front of the camera too much, he told me I was beautiful and the only problem I’d have showing my face is making players too tongue-tied to speak to me.”
“Holy shit,” Caitlin breathed out. “He said those exact words?”
“Yes. He’s always been supportive like that.” I waved a hand. “But for a few very surreal seconds, I thought Nate was about to kiss me. Which is my mind playing tricks on me. It’s been a long week.”
“I watched you guys at your graduation party. He seemed a little more than supportive around you.”
“He’s an easy flirt. Like I said, we’re friends. He’s going through a bad time, and I’m helping him. That’s it.”
“Then why are you chewing on your bottom lip like you’re about to swallow it?”
My hand flew to my mouth as I released my lip.