AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

Until I Found You

Page 30

by Erika Kelly

As his gaze lingered on her phone, she knew she’d made him uncomfortable reading her personal business out loud.

But she was glad she had. Seeing my mom through someone else’s eyes changes the whole picture. “When I first read it, all I heard was how I’d made a fool of myself in front of everyone. How Kendall ‘got the guy.’ But now, hearing you read it… My mom’s so cold. I mean, I’m her daughter. She knew Nate and I were together⁠—”

“Hang on. Catch me up.”

Fair point. He had no context for the message. “I went into the office this morning to tell him I was ready for more and found out he’d just proposed to my sister.”

“Well, fuck.”

Her skin felt hot, itchy, like an angry red rash had broken out all over it. “Yeah.” It all came flooding back, the shock, the mortification. “I just don’t understand how you can date two sisters in the same firm. My mom, Kendall…they had to know. All three of them were in on this.”

His gaze burned where it hit her cheek. He was worried about her, and she appreciated that more than she could say. Most of her life, she’d felt so alone.

Which was ironic, considering she literally worked in the same office as the woman who’d given birth to her.

And it struck her, that ache in childhood to have a mom? It had never gone away. A cool, soothing hand on her forehead when she was sick, a nonjudgmental ear when she needed advice. She’d grown up with an emptiness no amount of money or success could ever fill.

And she still had it. After all these years.

The pain was so intense, she felt nauseous.

The brake lights on the RV ahead of her flashed, and Willa tightened her grip on the steering wheel as she slowed.

“Your mom said Kendall’s better ‘suited’ for this guy,” Decker said. “Is she?”

“I don’t know. I’ve never seen them together outside of work.” Ever since she’d boarded the plane, she’d been scouring memories of the two of them together. Had she missed the secret looks? The chemistry? “Nate and I like the same things. We’re on the same path… I thought we were a good fit.”

“But it wasn’t love?”

“No. Definitely not.” She had a flash of Nate’s bare ass as he headed to the door to get the food they’d ordered. Twice, they’d spent the night with each other. Once, they’d banged in the supply closet on a stack of printing paper. But they’d never gone away together. And the only time they went out to dinner was on a work trip. “We didn’t date. We hooked up.”

“Did anything happen the last time you saw him? A fight? Bad sex?”

The clutch of tension around her heart eased. This was good, the forensic breakdown. It was exactly what she needed. “No.” The haze cleared, and she was finally calm enough to see the truth. “The last time we were together, I asked if he wanted to go to Martha’s Vineyard with me the next weekend. He was shaving and said, ‘Can’t.’ That was it. ‘Can’t.’ And then he rinsed off his face. His reaction embarrassed me, so I ran out of there like I’d just told a telemarketer I loved them.”

“It sounds like you’re more hurt about the betrayal than losing the guy.”

“That’s…” What was she going to do, pretend? “Yes.” As embarrassing as it was to admit it, she had to get a handle on the situation. How else could she go back to work on Monday? “I’m thirty-one. It seemed like the right time, right man. Who could be better for me than a partner who’s as busy and ambitious as I am?”

He tipped back his cup and drained the coffee. “Well, look, I’m not hearing you say he was funny or smart, that he took care of you when you were sick or came over in the middle of the night to kill a spider, so if your only criteria is someone who works as hard as you, then it shouldn’t be hard to find his replacement.”

“Did I say I liked your bluntness?”

“Oh, yeah. You highly praised it.”

“Well, I was wrong.”

“Truth hurts.”

He had her there. “Did you ever take care of a woman when she was sick? Did you ever go over in the middle of the night to kill a spider?”

“Yes. And yes.”

“Okay, you’re either lying or you have spent more than one night with a woman.” But really, why did she care so much about his love life? Her interest in him was bothersome.

“I don’t lie.” He cut her a look. “I don’t need to. And I’m talking about Ava. When I was fifteen, she didn’t pick me up after football practice. I waited two hours. Some of the moms pulled over and asked if I wanted a ride. Even Coach tried to take me home, but I said, ‘Nope. Ava’s coming.’” He paused. “But she didn’t.”

“What was wrong with her?”