AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

Merry Misconduct

Page 55

by Katie Bailey

“I think she might like it.” Dallas gives me an indulgent smile before winking at Maria.

I put a hand over my mouth as I swallow, then nod. “So, so good.”

“I’m glad you think so.” She pushes another plate towards us—a trio of goat cheese tartlets, wagyu sliders, and mini salad cups with walnut dressing and winter berries. “Tell me, how did you two first meet?”

My eyes widen, and I stuff a whole goat cheese tartlet in my mouth before looking at Dallas. Not it. Right or not, if he can start telling the tale, he can also be the one to finish it.

Casual as all hell, Dallas drapes an arm loosely on the back of my chair, taking it all in his stride. “It’s kind of a funny story...we met on the rooftop of a party we were both trying to avoid. I was having a bad night, so I went up there to be alone, and then the most beautiful woman I’d ever seen scared the hell out of me by asking for the time.”

He looks over at me with a pause, like he’s waiting to see if I want to add anything. I swallow my bite of food and dab my mouth with a napkin. “He screamed like a little girl.”

Dallas’s head falls back as he barks a surprised laugh. “I did,” he confirms with a grin.

Maria’s leaning in, fully invested. “Why were you having a bad night, if you don’t mind me asking?”

“I was meant to be on a date, but instead I ended up doing something for my boss to fix a mistake I’d made at work. I decided to go to the party when I was done to meet my supposed date, and found her locking lips with one of my coworkers on the dancefloor. After that, I was ready to go home, but something made me stay. Went up to the roof for some air, and well—” Dallas chuckles “—the rest is history.”

“Is that what happened, sweetheart?” I ask with a strained laugh.

I have no way to know if any of this is in the least bit true, but I wouldn’t be off brand for Dallas to have been on another date when we met. He probably just made up the bit about his date kissing someone else… more likely she caught him kissing someone else and he had to flee to the roof to escape her (justified) wrath.

Even as I think this, I somehow know it’s not true, though.

“You never told me you were supposed to be on a date with another woman that night,” I add, keeping my voice playful and flirty.

“That’s because I never gave her another single thought after I met you.” Dallas fixes his eyes on me. “Never gave any other woman a single thought.”

He’s laying it on thick, but it’s working, because Maria puts a hand over her heart. “Awh!” she simpers. “That’s impressive.”

“Extra impressive because he had quite a reputation before he settled down with me, you know,” I add with a little wink.

“All deserved, I’m afraid,” Dallas says, blushing in a way that makes him look equal parts bashful and more edible than the crostinis.

Robbie’s mouth is twisted in suspicion as he frowns at this, but Maria’s wriggling in her seat with anticipation. “So you met your beautiful bride on the roof that night, and she made you change your ways?”

“She changed everything.” Dallas’s arm is still loosely draped on the back of my chair, but his grip has tightened on it. And even as I tilt my head to look at him, he keeps his gaze straight, not meeting my eyes as he says, “I just didn’t let myself believe it at the time.”

“How so?” Robbie quirks a brow.

“I was an idiot.” I watch his Adam’s apple move along the thick, tanned column of his throat as he clears it and continues, “And after spending a whole night getting to know the most amazing woman I’d ever met, I never called her.”

I sputter a cough, then pat my chest and reach for my water glass to hide my surprise. Not the direction I was expecting him to take here to win over Maria. Where’s he going with this?

“No!” Maria’s eyes are bigger than the forgotten dinner plates in front of us.

“Unfortunately, yes. I told myself I had to put my career first, and that she wouldn’t want me anyway once she found out the type of guy I really was…”

I stare at him openmouthed, forgetting our facade for a moment.

If Dallas is fabricating this on the spot right now, he deserves a damn Oscar. Yet I can’t help but think that if he were truly trying to convince these people we’re a couple in love, he would’ve made up a much better story. One that involved a room full of rose petals and swans and choir boys singing “All of Me” in falsetto…although walking into a room like that would be more of a creepy fever dream than a romantic haven, now that I think about it.

When Dallas finally looks at me his eyes are stormy; Atlantic blue during a hurricane. “She was on my mind every day after that, and I thought I’d lost her forever…until fate brought her back into my life.”

“Wow,” Robbie says, his tone smooth yet somehow prickly. “That’s quite the story.”

Dallas’s face falters for a fraction of a second, like he’s just remembered where he is and who we’re talking to. He catches himself in record time though, turning to Robbie and Maria with a big smile. “Against all odds, she gave me a second chance I didn’t deserve, and let me redeem myself. And now she’s agreed to marry me…so here we are.”

There’s a beat of silence, before Maria reaches over and pats Dallas on the hand. “The fact that you can be vulnerable enough to admit you were wrong and own it tells me everything I need to know. I can see in your eyes just how painful that was for you, and how much you love your fiancée.” She turns and pats my hand next. “And how much you love him back, have changed him for the better. Also, just so you know—I’m in. The catering contract is yours, if you want it. It will be an honor to give up my holiday break to provide the food for your wedding.”