Page 9
He was holding a length of copper wire, doubled over and held loosely between both fists. He was holding it in the way a man might hold a jump rope before he began to turn it.
Warren took a step backward and his heel caught the edge of the gravel. He shifted his weight to recover, but never took his eyes away from the man’s face. The morning light was coming up across the desert behind the man's right shoulder and it caught the wire and made it bright.
He got one more look at the face before the wire came up, and in that last clear second the wrongness finally named itself. The face was real, but the skin was wrong along the underside of the jaw, up into the cheekbones.
He had just enough time to recognize it as some sort of harsh scarring before the wire came around and the world went sideways. The last thing Warren registered before the copper was fully around his neck was the dry mineral smell of the morning air coming through the gap in the guardrail, exactly as good as it always was.
The desert below was still in shadow. The saguaros held their long lines westward. Forty miles out, the distant mountains were beginning to separate themselves from the sky as the light came up, but Warren understood he would not get to see it in full.
CHAPTER EIGHT
There was a single large oak tree in the small clearing of grass outside of Dr. Mitchell’s office. The office was on the fourth floor, so all Miles could see was the top of it, the wandering branches and lush leaves. He had spent a lot of time looking at that tree over the past six months. He was looking at it now while Mitchell waited for him to finish the thought he had started and then let trail off.
“It felt like relief,” he said. “And then the relief felt wrong.”
“Why wrong?” Mitchell asked.
“Because thirty-four people are dead. And the reason we finally got in front of it, the reason we knew enough to identify Caswell's purchase pattern and build the profile and get there in time, is because of those thirty-four people. We learned from every one of those cases. We got better because of them.” He looked at the tree, as if hoping some better explanation might be hiding in those branches. “That's a difficult thing to sit with.”
“I’m sure it is,” Mitchell said. She did not rush past it or offer a reframe, which was one of the things he had come to appreciate about her. “Can you explain that a bit more? Maybe about what sitting with it feels like?”
He thought about it for a while and understood that it was a question he may have tried to dodge just a few weeks ago. After about twenty seconds, he did the best he could. “It feels like the relief is built on something I shouldn't be relieved about. I know the deaths weren't necessary in some designed sense, that no one chose to let them happen in order to improve our methodology. But the sequence is real. Eleven cases came before this one, and we didn't save anyone in those eleven cases. And by the time Tucson came around we were good enough to save Paula Oñate. Those two facts exist in the same timeline.”
“And you feel responsible for the connection between them,” Mitchell said.
“I feel aware of it,” Miles said. “That's probably a more accurate way of saying it.”
“Is there a difference, for you?”
He thought about that seriously. "I think so. Responsibility implies I could have altered the timeline somehow, but I don't think I could have. The task force was doing the work from the beginning. We weren't failing because we weren't trying." He shifted in the chair. "I think what I'm actually working through is the guilt of feeling good about something that has a very dark foundation. Like, I don't have the right to feel the relief cleanly."
He was rather surprised that he’d explained it so succinctly. It made him feel not only understood but sort of clear for the first time in far too long.
“Do you think that's a reasonable standard to hold yourself to?” Dr. Mitchell asked.
“No,” he said, without much hesitation. “But knowing it's unreasonable doesn't make it go away.”
Mitchell made a brief note on her tablet. "What did the relief actually feel like, in the moment? In the warehouse, when you reach her."
Miles had not talked about the specific moment in any detail with anyone. He had written it into the after-action report in the flat, procedural language those reports required, and he had described it to Hayes in the Zoom call in the same sparse language. But the actual experience of it was something he had kept to himself, not deliberately, but because there had been no obvious moment to put it into words.
“I crouched down next to her and checked her pulse,” he said. “And when I felt it, there was about two seconds where I didn't do anything. I just stayed there.” He finally looked away from the tree and sighed. “After arriving at so many murder scenes, I guess you develop a kind of bracing habit. You prepare for the version where you're too late even when you don't know yet. And when the pulse was there and she was breathing, the bracing just came apart. It was very physical, actually.”
“That sounds like a significant moment,” Mitchell said.
“It was the first time I've felt actually successful in this investigation,” Miles said. “Not procedurally successful. Actually successful. But it doesn't fix anything that came before it. But it wasn't nothing.”
“No,” Mitchell agreed. “It wasn't nothing.”
He caught her smiling, which he thought was a good sign. It wasn’t something he saw much of in his sessions with her. “Is there anyone you wish you could have told that to? The feeling of success, I mean?”
He hadn't expected the question and it took him a moment. For some reason, he felt emotion surging up inside of him. He knew who came forward first and he didn't try to push the image back. Elana, three months before she died, sitting cross-legged on the living room floor with a canvas propped against the couch and a brush she was holding like a child might hold a pencil. She had been laughing at herself, explaining that she wasn't sure she was getting it right but that the getting-it-right part didn't seem like the point.
“Maybe,” he said.
“Elana?” she asked, almost whispering the name.
“Yeah, Elana.”