Page 21
“When did you figure that out?”
“After the Caswell arrest. When I saw Marsh's coverage and realized the details she had were from the discovery materials, I started trying to reach Oak and couldn't. And then I looked closer at the credentials he'd given me.” He took his glasses off and set them on the desk. “I know how it looks. I understand that. I should have paid more attention when I first met him but I guess I got wrapped up in the idea of assisting with a documentary.”
“Walk me through the meeting at the coffee shop,” Vic said.
"He bought the coffee, and as soon as I sat down, he asked if it was okay if he used a recorder. I told him that was fine. He asked me about the case in general terms first, about how the public defender's office was approaching the defense, what the discovery materials indicated about the prosecution's theory. I kept it general. But then he got more specific about the physical evidence, about the wire technique and what the forensic documentation showed." Yuen put his glasses back on and leaned forward a bit. "He framed it as background for the film. He said he wanted to understand the method so he could explain it to a general audience accurately. And I..." He stopped.
“You told him,” Vic said.
“I did. He offered a consulting fee of fifteen hundred dollars, paid to a Venmo account. I have the transaction if you need it.” He said this without making it sound like he thought the transaction record would help him. “I told him the wire gauge, the overlap pattern, the loop closure technique. I told him about the burn site placement, too. Honestly, I figured it was information that would eventually all come out, anyway.” He sat back and let out a small sigh. “He already seemed to know most of it, anyway. He was asking for confirmation more than information.”
Vic kept her expression even. “What did he look like?”
“I'd say somewhere around sixty, maybe a little older. Lean, not tall. And he was very deliberate when he talked. Not slow, just...” He searched for the word and finally settled on: “Measured. Like each sentence was something he'd decided on before he said it.”
“Was there anything physically distinctive about him?”
“Nothing that I can think of. I did notice that it was strange that he kept his collar up. I noticed a few times when he reached for it to make sure it was still in place. But it wasn’t cold in the shop. But at one point, he reached across the table for the recorder and his collar shifted. I could see his neck, below the jaw line. There was scarring. It looked pretty significant. He pulled the collar back up pretty quickly. I guess he was just trying to hide it.”
Vic sat with that for a moment without changing her posture or her expression. Scarring. It took her mind to a very specific place, but she kept it in check for the time being.
“Did he say anything else about the film?” she said. “Distribution, release, anything like that?”
“He said it was in early development. He mentioned a festival submission he was aiming for but I can't remember which one.” Yuen shook his head. “Everything he said was very plausible. That was what got me. None of it had any obvious holes until I went looking afterward.”
“Did he express any opinion about the case? About Caswell or about the Elementalist investigation generally?”
Yuen thought about it for a moment before going on. "He said the investigation had been mishandled in terms of public communication. That the bureau was treating the ideology behind the cases as something to be suppressed rather than understood, he seemed to have strong feelings about that…but it didn't come across as angry. It was more like he found it genuinely frustrating from an intellectual standpoint. Like he thought the public was being underserved."
Vic nodded once. “The Venmo account you mentioned...can you send me the username and transaction ID?”
“Yes, of course.” He reached for his phone immediately, clearly relieved to have something concrete to offer. He pulled up the transaction and read her the details while she entered them into her phone.
“Is there anything else you remember about him?” Vic asked. “How he arrived, what he was driving, anything about where he said he was based?”
“He said he was based in Los Angeles. I don't know how he arrived. I was already there when he came in.” Yuen set his phone down. “I know I should have verified the credentials more carefully before that meeting. I understand that. I just want you to know that from my perspective he was entirely convincing. I had no real reason to doubt him.”
“I understand,” Vic said. She stood up and he stood with her, almost perfectly in sync. “If you think of anything else, I'd like you to call me directly.” She handed him a card and he took it with both hands.
“I will. And I am truly sorry if any of this has made things harder on you or the task force.”
She said nothing, not wanting to tell him about the murder at the copper mine. She left the office and took the stairs rather than the elevator, moving through the building exit and back onto North Stone Avenue. The heat outside was immediate and almost pressing. She walked half a block to where there was a narrow strip of shade thrown by an awning over a closed storefront, and she stopped there.
She considered what she knew. The man had given what turned out to be a false name. He was an older man, lean, deliberate in speech. But honestly, none of that really seemed to matter. It was the business with the collar that had her hooked…a collar he kept up to hide scarring. Even the fake credentials and fake production company didn’t seem to be as important as a very defining trait like that.
And then there was the thing Yuen had said almost as an afterthought—that “Mr. Oak” already seemed to know most of it. He was asking for confirmation more than information.
Vic stood in the shade and looked at the street without focusing on anything in it. A bus went by at the far end of the block. The awning above her shifted once in a brief movement of air and then went still while she took out her phone and called Miles.
He answered on the second ring. “How did it go?”
“Well, Marsh isn’t the big story anymore.”
“How so?”
“Yuen was approached by someone presenting as a documentary filmmaker,” she said, getting right to the meat of the matter. “The name was Lawrence Oak. But his credentials were fabricated, and the website of a production company he claimed to have worked for doesn’t exist. The name’s a fake, too. He paid Yuen fifteen hundred dollars through Venmo for a consulting session where Yuen confirmed the wire technique details and the burn site documentation.”
“When?”