Page 75
Jasper’s face pops into my mind without my permission. His dark brown eyes. That stupid cowboy mullet. The mustache that tickled my skin as his mouth seared kisses all over my body. Lying here, I can practically feel the weight of him on top of me. Feel the warmth of his bare skin against mine. Despite knowing I never should’ve let things get as far as they did, I can’t deny how fucking good it felt having his cock slide against mine. He wanted it just as badly as I did.
My hips thrust forward as my hand slips behind my underwear. It’s like my body is moving of its own accord and I have no say in the matter. I groan softly as my fingers wrap around the base, stroking all the way to the tip. My eyes roll back. It feels so fucking good, I couldn’t stop this even if I tried.
Jasper’s rough moans surround me as I relive the famished way he sucked my cock, like making me feel good brought him genuine pleasure. He swallowed every last inch with ease, peering up at me from beneath wet lashes like every filthy fantasy I’ve ever had. We were both impatient and drowning in fervor by the time he pulled away. I couldn’t get inside him fast enough. And fuck, he was so tight and warm and fucking perfect.
Heat radiates through my body as my fist flies up and down my length with desperation. I’m chasing the pleasure I felt buried deep in his ass, and even though this doesn’t even come close, I still don’t stop. I need this. I reach down with my other hand, rolling my full balls in my palm as I grip my cock tighter.
“Fuck.”
My back arches off the bed. I sink my teeth into my bottom lip, hard enough to draw blood, trying not to make a sound, but I can’t help it. In my mind, I’m in Jasper’s kitchen, and he’s bent over the counter, heated eyes full of lust as they look at me over his shoulder. His hole grips my cock, his muscles bunch under my touch, and sweat drips from my pores as I thrust into him with years of memories and longing driving me.
A groan rips from my chest as everything in me tenses. My body is on fire, and I can’t hold on any longer. It takes me by surprise how quickly and strongly my release hits me. It consumes me. I gasp as my balls tighten and my cock swells. It’s Jasper’s face behind my eyes as thick spurts cover my hand and stomach. My pulse roars as I ride the high, stroking myself until every last drop comes out.
Much to my annoyance, it doesn’t take long for reality to catch up to me. Lying here, out of breath, with cum splashed over my skin, one thing becomes abundantly clear…
I didn’t come back to Honey Creek to get away from Jasper.
I came here because I was afraid of how much I wanted to go back to him. And I don’t know what I’m supposed to do with that realization.
Chapter Twenty-Three
Jasper
Ispot Magnolia the second she strolls into the coffee shop. She’s impossible to miss in her white sundress with strawberries all over and her bright, infectious smile. It’s nine-thirty on a Sunday morning, and we’re at our favorite place to grab coffee on Main Street. We’ve been meeting here or at my place every Sunday since we were old enough to drive ourselves into town.
Except lately, there haven’t been a whole lot of these Sunday friend dates. Things at the ranch have been relentless. Between Chesney being there every single weekday morning, the dude ranch slowly coming to fruition, and a busy breeding season, I haven’t had a chance to breathe, much less keep up with commitments that aren’t ranch related. But I needed to make time for this. I needed my best friend today. My head’s all over the place.
Waving Magnolia over, I take a sip from my coffee mug. It’s almost a little too hot to drink, but that’s when it tastes the best so I don’t mind. As she crosses the room toward our favorite spot near the back window, she’s watching me with an expression I can’t place, almost like she’s studying me, and when she reaches our table, she slides onto the seat across from me, her eyes never leaving mine.
Before I have a chance to say hi, her eyebrows lift, like she’s made some grand realization, and she swats my arm. “Oh my gosh. You had sex with him, didn’t you?”
I nearly choke on my coffee. “What? Why would you think that?”
“You totally did!”
“Well, good morning to you too,” I murmur before taking another drink, hoping to pivot the conversation.
“Don’t ‘good morning’ me, Jasper Theordore Smith.”
My brows pinch, and I breathe out a laugh. “That’s not even my middle name.”
“And that’s not even the point.” Magnolia points at me, lowering her voice. “Admit it.”
I shrug. “Not sure what you’re talking about.”
“Oh, bullshit.” She chuckles. “You look like a man who made a very bad decision and is currently trying to convince yourself it was a good one.”
In all the years Magnolia and I have known each other, we’ve gotten pretty good at reading each other. When one of us is upset or stressed or anxious, the other can feel it before it’s ever spoken aloud. So, while I’d like to say I’m surprised she guessed that so quickly, I’m really not.
When I came here this morning, I wasn’t sure if I even wanted to tell her about what happened with Chesney. It was intense, and hot, and really fucking confusing. It’s been two days, and I still don’t know how I feel about it.
But clearly, it’s written all over my face like a scarlet letter.
“Okay, yes,” I say slowly, keeping my voice quiet. The last thing I need is for the town gossips to do their thing and have it make its way back to Chesney. Not that he ever gets out and interacts with anyone, but still. “But I’m sure it was just a one-time thing. It’s not a big deal.”
“Not a big deal?” Magnolia leans forward, eyes wide. “I’ve known you since we were kids. I watched you spend half your teenage years sneaking around with Chesney Jennings. I watched you come home after he broke your heart. I watched you spend years pretending you didn’t care about him.” She pauses, taking me in. “And now you’re sitting across from me looking like you haven’t slept. I’d definitely say that constitutes as somewhat of a big deal.”
I look down at my coffee. The steam has mostly disappeared, but the mug is still keeping my hands warm. My chest is tight, and I don’t know if it’s with regret or confusion or disappointment in myself. “I don’t know what I’m doing.”