AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

Burning Love

Page 71

by Ashley James

I’m met with silence. Tense, heartbreaking silence.

But then Chesney laughs humorlessly once more. “You know what I keep thinking?” His voice drops so low I nearly miss it. “If I’d just stayed home…”

My stomach twists. “Chesney.”

“I would’ve heard him.”

“No.”

“I would’ve been there. He never would’ve been trampled.”

“No! Stop.”

The pain in his voice guts me. “If I’d just stayed home, I could’ve⁠—”

“You don’t know that,” I say, louder than I intended. The tears I’ve been trying to hold back spill over, cascading down my face as Chesney angrily wipes his cheek with the sleeve of his hoodie.

“I do know that,” he growls.

“No.” I take another step, closing the distance between us. This time, he doesn’t react. “You don’t.”

Chesney’s breath is uneven and shallow, like he can’t seem to get enough air. “I left.” His voice breaks completely. “I left him.”

“You were gone for an hour,” I say softly, wanting to calm him down.

“I shouldn’t have gone at all,” he booms. “I left and he died, Jasper. Lyle fucking died.”

His legs give out and he collapses to his knees. Hanging his head in his hands, Chesney sobs. His shoulders shake, and he completely folds in on himself. There’s nothing I can say to make it right, and there’s nothing I can do that will bring Lyle back. I kneel in the grass in front of him, cautiously placing my arm on his shoulder. Tears stream hot down my face as he falls apart. And I fall apart with him. For the agony he’s feeling. For the life taken from this earth way too soon. For the devastating realization that Chesney will never get to watch his brother grow up.

None of this feels real.

None of it is fair.

“Chesney, you couldn’t have known,” I say after a few minutes.

“But I did.” He lifts his head, finally looking directly at me. The guilt in his eyes is almost unbearable. “I chose you.” Another sob escapes him as he shoves a finger into my chest. “I chose you over being home. And n-now Lyle’s gone. He’s gone forever because I. Chose. You.”

The realization of what he’s saying physically hurts. I can’t breathe. “No.” Reaching for him instinctively, I say, “No. You don’t get to carry that.”

Chesney’s expression changes from grief to anger in the blink of an eye. “I don’t?” He shoves my hand away and gets to his feet, taking a step back. Away from me.

My legs nearly give out when I stand, but this time, I don’t move closer. Shaking my head desperately, I say, “It wasn’t your fault.”

“It was, though.”

“No, it wasn’t.”

“It was!” The shout tears through the night. “If I hadn’t come to meet you⁠—”

“Stop,” I whisper, my chin quivering.

“He’d still be alive. He’d still be alive.”

“Chesney!” His name rips from my throat, but he doesn’t hear it. Or maybe he does. Maybe he just doesn’t care.

His breathing comes in ragged bursts now. “I keep replaying it,” he says, pressing the heel of his hand into his eye. “Over and over and over and fucking over again.”

I reach for him again. I can’t stand watching him unravel.