Page 63
Jasper grabs another letter from the box and reads it in its entirety before shoving it into my chest and grabbing the next one. This goes on for a while, and somehow, each letter is worse than the last. Or, better, I guess, depending on perspective.
Finally, he huffs out a breath and looks at me. “There’s no fucking way.”
I point toward the signature on bottom of the page. “You tell me.”
Jasper’s grandfather’s name stares back at us. The ink has bled a little bit, and the handwriting isn’t as great as the other signature. But still, it’s legible. Clyde Smith. Grabbing another one we’ve already read, I slam it onto the desk in front of him, my finger landing beside the second signature. Helen Jennings. Neither of us speaks. I don’t even think we breathe. Because there’s one explanation—only one—and it’s absolutely insane.
“My grandfather…” Jasper starts, his voice low and quiet.
“And my grandmother…” My heart is in my throat as my eyes scan the faded, old pages again, one right after another, until I can’t stand to look anymore. Clyde Smith and my grandmother... “They had a fucking affair.”
“Look at the dates,” Jasper murmurs. “This went on for years.”
My brain struggles to catch up. An affair. A years-long affair.
What…the…fuck?
“If this is actually true…” I hardly recognize my own voice. “If this is true, that means the feud, the rivalry, the decades of anger and bitterness and separation… All of it’s because two people couldn’t keep their hands off each other.”
“Oh my god. I’m gonna be sick.” Jasper drops into his chair, eyes wide open, eyebrows shot up to his hairline. He looks horrified as he runs his fingers through his hair. And I don’t blame him. It’s exactly how I feel. “This can’t be real. It just can’t. There’s no way.”
We sort through more of the box and, unfortunately, it is real. The evidence is all right here, wrapped in a neat little bow. Years’ worth of letters, full of promises, declarations, plans. This is the kind of love story that would’ve made small-town gossip explode if it got out. Which, apparently, it never did. If anybody knew about this, they took it to the grave.
All these years. The hatred. The pain. And neither family even knew the actual reason anymore. They just inherited the anger, passing it down like property.
Jasper leans back slowly, looking shell-shocked. I probably look the same. Then he does the last thing I expected from him… He laughs. Not because it’s funny, but because it’s ridiculous. Because what else are you supposed to do when you accidentally uncover a secret big enough to destroy entire families? Soon, we’re both laughing, utterly stunned, while sitting in the middle of an office buried beneath upwards of sixty years of secrets.
“My dad’s going to lose his fucking mind,” I say, rubbing a hand over the back of my neck.
“Your grandmother literally caused a generational blood feud.”
“Hey.” I point accusingly. “So did your grandfather.”
Jasper snorts. “Fair.”
Then we’re laughing again, harder this time. And for a few minutes, that’s all there is. Just us, the letters, and the realization that our families had spent decades hating each other over a love story nobody bothered explaining. They spent decades hating each other over infidelity that had nothing to do with them.
Eventually, the laughter fades, and the room goes quiet again. There’s a heaviness that settles between us.
Jasper picks up one of the letters and reads part of it. Then shakes his head and looks at me. Something shifts in his expression. His eyes are soft, steady. “I guess they couldn’t stay away from each other either.”
The words hit hard—harder than they should—puncturing something in my chest. My throat tightens and my pulse thunders. The way he’s looking at me isn’t helping. The office suddenly feels too warm, too quiet, too small. It’s suffocating, and dangerous. But then I clear my throat and look away. That’s much safer, even if part of me knows we’re both thinking about the exact same thing.
By the time we finish sorting through the letters, it’s nearly midnight. The office looks significantly less like a disaster zone, and my entire understanding of my family’s history has been shattered.
I lean back in my chair and stare at the ceiling. “So.”
Jasper snorts. “So.”
Neither of us knows what to do with this information. My grandmother and his grandfather—years of letters, of lies, of loving each other enough to destroy two families in the process. It’s too much to wrap my head around. It’s absurd, and heartbreaking, and maybe even a little romantic, if I’m being honest.
My head is a mess.
“I should probably head home,” I say softly. “I’m fucking beat.”
“Me too.” Jasper groans dramatically, stretching his arms over his head. “I’m taking my ass to bed as soon as I eat something.”
“We should’ve ordered a pizza,” I murmur. My stomach growls right on cue. “The idea of finding something to make at the house is miserable.”