AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

Burning Love

Page 61

by Ashley James

He shrugs. “Just doesn’t seem like you.”

“Yeah, well, I had a hard year.”

“Why, what happened?”

My chest tightens as sweat pricks at the back of my neck. “Come on, Chesney.”

He swipes the file sitting between us, taking a quick look inside. I see the exact moment it clicks. Lowering the folder slowly, he rubs his hand along his jaw, his eyes watching me with such intensity that it sends goosebumps across my body. “You said junior year.”

It’s not a question. We both know why junior year was hard without either of us having to clarify. But I nod anyway, my throat thick with emotion I wasn’t expecting to feel today.

“I didn’t know,” is all he says. It slices into me like a dagger to the chest, and I don’t know whether I should laugh or get pissed off.

“How could you?” I ask, the words coming out sharper than I intended them to. “It’s not like you stuck around long enough to find out.”

Chesney rears back as if I’d slapped him. He doesn’t say anything for a moment, hurt flashing in his eyes, his voice hollow. “That’s not fair.”

“You’re right. I’m sorry.” Something twists painfully in my stomach, and I regret what I said immediately. “I can’t even begin to imagine what you must’ve been going through back then. But losing Lyle hurt me as well. Then losing you right after—the things you said and how easily you cut me off… It felt like you died that night too.”

Before the accident, I’d gotten close with Lyle over the years. He was the only Jennings who knew about mine and Chesney’s friendship, and in turn, he spent a lot of time hanging out with us. When he died, it really fucked me up.

The air around us shifts. My heart thrashes as I wait to see how Chesney reacts to what I’ve spent years holding inside. What I’ve spent years wishing I could say to him. His jaw pops as he exhales a sharp breath through his nose. This could turn ugly really fast. Hell, it could erase all the progress we’ve made working together. But as I sit here, with my heart in my throat, I realize I’m okay with that. I’m okay taking that risk because this is a conversation Chesney and I should’ve had years ago.

It’s long overdue.

He swallows harshly, and his gaze softens. “I guess I was so full of grief and self-loathing that I never even stopped to consider anybody else’s feelings.”

“I was a mess for a long fucking time, Chesney.” My voice cracks as I’m taken back to that time. “And I had nobody to talk to. Our whole friendship was a secret. Nobody knew what I was going through, and keeping all that inside fucked me up. I couldn’t handle it anymore. Then, when I started spending more time in detention, I got closer to Todd, and eventually, let it all out. He was one of the only people there for me after you left. When Lyle died, it felt like I lost a brother. And then you…” I shake my head, clearing my throat. “You left me.”

“I…had to,” he murmurs, his eyes wet and bloodshot. “I couldn’t stay here, Jasper. I couldn’t live in that house, couldn’t walk through those pastures. I couldn’t go on living in this town, with all those memories, knowing Lyle was never coming home. And knowing I was the reason he was gone.”

“What?” A choked sob comes out of me as tears spill over and roll down my cheeks. “You are not the reason Lyle died. You were just a kid.”

Chesney clears his throat, then wipes the moisture from under his eyes. “I know that now,” he says gruffly. “But it took many years in therapy and a whole lot of self-reflection to actually believe that.”

This explains so much.

“Does your family know you were carrying all that guilt?”

“Truett does. But I didn’t open up to him about it until about ten years after Lyle’s death.”

My heart hurts so unbelievably badly for Chesney and the pain he went through. Not just from grieving the loss of his younger brother, but from how much he held himself responsible for all those years. That would wreck anybody.

“I wish you would’ve let me be there for you,” I say softly. “Even if you had to leave, I would’ve still been someone to lean on.”

Chesney holds my gaze for a long moment. He looks torn, like there’s something he wants to say but doesn’t know if he should. Before he even says a word, there’s a sinking pit in my stomach and the hairs on the back of my neck stand on end.

Looking away, he inhales a deep breath, exhaling it slowly. “For longer than I care to admit, I thought that if it weren’t for us being friends—or well, more than friends—I never would’ve been tempted to sneak away that night. I never would’ve carelessly left the gate unsecured, causing the cattle to get loose, and Lyle never would’ve felt like he needed to herd them back in. When he was dying, I was with you.” He finally meets my gaze. The sorrow in his eyes steals my breath away. “I was with someone from the same family my dad always warned me about. If felt like his death was the universe punishing me for going against my father’s wishes. For caring about you when I shouldn’t have.”

My throat aches, and the pressure behind my eyes is almost unbearable. I try to blink back more tears blurring my vision, but it doesn’t work. They fall hot down my face anyway.

I’ve spent years wondering how he could leave me, how he could be as cruel as he was, and now that I know the truth, I don’t know what to do with it. It never would’ve been possible to be there for Chesney after that night, to comfort him through his grief the way I yearned to for years and years. In his mind, his connection to me—his feelings for me—is what led to his brother’s death.

“You didn’t cause this,” I murmur. “Us caring for each other didn’t cause this. Chesney, what happened that night was an accident. A tragic, unfair accident that nobody could’ve predicted. It kills me knowing you spent any amount of time thinking anything you did or felt could’ve been responsible for that. You were sixteen. You were just a kid. To carry that amount of guilt so young, for something you didn’t do, is awful. And to carry it alone for so long? You never deserved that.”

He’s quiet for a moment, the weight of everything hanging between us.

“I’m sorry, Jasper,” he eventually says. “For everything I said. For the way I treated you. And for not realizing how much it would’ve hurt you too.”