Page 11
The papers are calling him the Vendetta Killer, which I hate. It's got that tabloid stink on it, all alliteration and no information. But it stuck, the way stupid things do, and now it's what you have to type if you want anyone to find the articles.
Here's what's real about him, stripped of the branding.
Over roughly the last five years, men have been going missing from this city and the surrounding counties at a rate that's about eleven percent above what the population and the demographics predict. That's not enough to make anyone panic. It's barely enough to make a statistician squint. I only noticed because I was building a completely different data set for a completely different story and it bothered me for two weeks before I understood why.
When you look at the victims and start reading about them instead of the killer, a pattern shows up so fast it's almost rude.
Assault charges dropped for lack of evidence, restraining orders, a stalking complaint that went nowhere, a few from the sex registry, and a man whose ex-wife filed six separate reports over four years.
All these men have a great reason for someone to want to harm them, hell reading some of their stories, I wanted to harm them. But that’s the difference between me and this Vendetta guy, I don’t act on my impulses and he obviously does.
I write listicles. I want to be clear about that, because I think it's important to be honest about where you're standing. My byline for the last three years has been attached to things like Eleven Rooftop Bars That Won't Destroy Your Wallet and We Ranked Every Bagel in Astoria So You Don't Have To, and I am, humiliatingly, very good at it. Numbered lists are just structure. Structure is the only thing I've ever been naturally good at.
But I'm thirty, and I'd like to write something that matters before I'm forty. Martin told me in December that if I brought him something with actual reporting in it, real reporting, sourced and defensible, he'd move me to the crime desk.
So.
Six weeks ago, I put a tip line in the footer of one of my own listicles. Buried it under the fold, in eight-point type, where nobody would care and legal wouldn't notice. Know something about the Vendetta Killer? Write to me.
I got two hundred emails. A hundred and ninety-six of them were nothing: conspiracy theorists, a man who wanted to talk about lizards, four separate people confessing to it in a way that made clear they'd never so much as jaywalked.
Three were interesting.
One was three words.
Try West Chelsea.
That's it. Sent from an address that had been created nine minutes earlier and deleted before I finished reading it.
It's nothing. Any reasonable person would tell you it's nothing. I got on the train anyway. Then I booked two weeks in a walk-up on the West Side, because the paper won't expense a hotel for a story I haven't told them I'm writing.
Now it's a Thursday, a quarter past ten, and it's raining, making my glasses useless, so I've stopped trying to wipe them since Fourteenth Street.
Bar number ten is on a corner I've walked past twice already without registering, which is its own kind of interesting. It's got a black awning and no signage on the street except a small brass plate beside the door that says:
KARMA
That's it. No hours, no menu, no chalkboard promising two-for-one anything.
I stand in the rain and look at it, already knowing something's different. I don't like knowing things before I can explain them. It makes me itchy.
Then I go in.
It’s warm, that’s the first thing I notice. Not warm like a temperature, warm like a color. Amber lighting, low, coming from about twenty different sources instead of four, which means there isn't a shadow anywhere in the room.
I stop three steps inside the door and just look. If that makes me strange, then it makes me strange, because it's a thing I do and I've stopped apologizing for it.
No booths, that's the second thing. Every table in this room is round and visible from the bar. There's no corner you could take someone to. There's no back hallway you could steer somebody down, because the bathrooms are right there off the main floor with the doors in full view, and the hall to them is four feet long and lit like a hospital.
The bar itself runs the length of the far wall so whoever's behind it is facing everything. There are cameras. I count five, and they're not the fake kind; they're not hidden either, which tells you they're not there to catch anyone. They're there to be seen.
There's a sign by the door. Small, framed, hand-lettered, not a printout:
Ask for a ride home. Any hour, any distance. It's free. It's always free.
I read it twice.
I'm a person who notices things. It's the only genuinely useful trait I have, and it comes bundled with a bunch that aren't. But there's noticing a detail, and then there's the thing that's happening to me right now, which is standing in a doorway in a wet coat.