AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

The Other Side of Starting Over

Page 85

by Mara Williams

He strides over to me in two steps and reaches for my hand. “Do you trust me?”

Isn’t that a loaded question. I don’t answer but give him my hand anyway.

Five minutes later, we’re outside on his deck, dressed only in towels. We’re getting a preview of the months to come, because the warm day has shifted to a brisk night. The air is fresh and new and clean. I stop at the top of the stairs to admire the view. This is the time I’ve always loved the lake best: when the moon shines across its back like a night-light, when it slumbers against the shoreline like a contented child, when it’s hushed and at peace and listening to your innermost thoughts.

Suncrest may be a town whose shine has dimmed, but the lake is still a star.

Simon snakes around me and bounds down to the dock, and I clue in. “No way,” I say. Until this moment, I thought he may have a hot tub hiding out here. But the only destination is the lake, and he’s delusional if he thinks I’m jumping in, no matter how beautiful it is shimmering under the canopy of constellations. I’m a local; I know how cold that water is.

Simon turns, gripping the railing as he grins at me. He’s rumpled and gorgeous, and his lips are red and swollen from me. “It’ll feel incredible.”

“I feel pretty damn good already.”

He tugs on his bottom lip with his teeth, releasing it with a smile. “Glad to hear it. But this”—he flicks his head to the water—“will change your life.”

When my bare feet connect with the dock, I’m filled with nostalgia more potent than memory from the soft give of wood over water, the creak of the floats, and the splash of the lake’s surface underneath. Simon drops his towel, and perhaps he led me here to show off his body lit up by the night sky, while the moon, the stars, and the reflection of the water conspire to intensify his beauty. Michelangelo couldn’t have sculpted a more perfect ass.

Simon glances over his shoulder, catching me leering, and, with a knowing smile, jogs and leaps off the dock. He comes up with a gasp, flinging his hair out of his eyes before waving to me.

“C’mon, Beatrice. It feels great.”

I laugh, clutching my towel to my chest. “Your teeth are chattering.”

“But it’ll wake you right up.”

“Or stop my heart.”

“I can restart it for you. I’m a paramedic, remember?” His breath comes out labored as he trembles from the chill.

I roll my eyes even though he can’t see it. His cheesy joke is telling a deeper truth than I care to admit. I feel a swell of warmth rushing to my chest and color returning to my face even as I stand here shivering at nightfall on the lake where I fell for my first and lost love.

This seems like a dare, but Simon waits for me like a promise, treading water in the spotlight of the moon. If I can brave the cold, he’ll be my reward.

I walk to the edge and drop my towel, and Simon’s smile grows. “You’re stunning,” he hums.

When I hold my breath and jump, Simon’s victory call is the last thing I hear before I emerge from the biting water, winded and wild, and shivering so relentlessly I want to climb right back out. But he pulls me into his warm arms, kissing me as he keeps us afloat. We’re a slick slide of skin, a tender press of soft lips, and a melody of low hums.

Maybe he was right, because it feels like his touch could restart my heart and give me new life. Or perhaps it’s this place—the lake, the pines, and the silence—giving me enough space to see hope bloom.

“I need to feed you,” Simon says as we part, floating on our backs to stare at the stars.

“I need to go.” I want to see the kids and hear about their night and let my optimism rub off on them.

He reaches for my fingertips. “Then let me take you out next week. A real date.”

And just like that, the impossibility of us is more of a wake-up call than diving into this frigid lake. I’m not ready to do anything that would destabilize the kids, especially considering the bomb I need to drop next week. I can’t have the kids thinking I’m dishonoring their dad, even if he dishonored me years ago. I don’t know what I’m ready for in any traditional sense. Simon can have my body—but my time, my attention? Neither of those are available right now. But why the hell do I become so distracted when he’s close to me? Why does he make me forget all the reasons I’ve been resisting him?

“Simon . . . because of the kids, I can’t . . .”

He swims to me, wrapping an arm around my waist until we’re entwined again. “I’m not asking for complicated. Just a date.”

“But with me, you get complicated whether you ask for it or not.”

“Your kids don’t have to know anything until you’re ready. We’ll make it a breakfast date while they’re at school.”

He makes it sound so easy. Perhaps it is simpler than I’m making it out to be. I’m a master at compartmentalizing and hiding my pain. Maybe I can do the same with my joy—tuck it into a small, safe corner in my life as I manage the upheaval to come.

Chapter 35