The Other Side of Starting Over
Page 71
She studies me, squaring her shoulders and settling her hands on the table. “And the wind has been knocked right outa ya, hasn’t it?”
I nod, biting my lip to keep it from quivering.
“Now, is this really about the kids’ questions, or about all the questions you have that you can’t ask?”
Gigi knows how to cut to the heart of the matter. She watches me behind her thick lenses, her blue eyes wide and waiting.
“Both, I think.” I glance out the window and watch a bird skate across the water’s surface, noting how still the lake is this morning.
“Well, that’s the worst of it, isn’t it? You can’t demand answers. You can’t be angry with him because you’re too busy missing him. You can’t lose it because you need to keep your shit together for the kids.”
“Oh, I’m plenty angry,” I say. “And I’m barely keeping it together. But I don’t know how I missed the signs or how Jake could do that to me. I thought he was my soulmate.” I laugh, but it sounds suspiciously like a cry. I hold my breath, waiting for the burst of emotion to pass.
She places her mug on the table, and it sloshes over the edge, staining the tablecloth with a ring of moisture. “Well, that’s your first mistake. There’s no such thing as soulmates, Bumblebee. We’re all just people doing our best, screwing up, and often hurting the ones we love most.”
“You don’t think Gramps was your soulmate?”
She tsks. “The idea of soulmates is a load of bologna that makes people think they’ve chosen the wrong person if it isn’t all sunshine and rainbows. Sure, there are people better suited than others. But basically, I believe in the right man at the right time with the right chemistry, and then love is the choice you make once the infatuation dies. It isn’t some divine order. Every once in a while, two people are lucky enough to make it last.”
“I misjudged Jake, I guess. He cheated before we even married. So he wasn’t the right guy at any time.”
“You don’t believe that, do you? About our Jake? You two adored each other. My guess? Take it with a grain of batty old salt. I think Jake did you wrong and then spent a lifetime trying to make it right.”
“You really think so?” I’m haunted by what-ifs, left wondering whether I was a fool who didn’t see his duplicitous side, who only met the veneer, even after more than two decades together.
She shrugs. “Or he could have been a sociopath like his mother.”
“Wow, thanks. That’s comforting.” I take a sip of my latte, swallowing her bitter pill with the bitterness of coffee.
“But I doubt it. Faye can only hold the ugly at bay for a blink. If Jake was deceiving us, he was certainly good at it. It’s more likely that he screwed up like a lot of men before him. He did pretty well, considering the vile hag who raised him.”
“But he lied to me for almost twenty years.” I don’t know what I’m looking for here, but it’s a relief to pose these questions to someone who loved him, too, but doesn’t have as much at stake in keeping his memory sanitized.
“Lies are about shame. They have nothing to do with who we love or who we don’t. There’s plenty I’ve lied about in my lifetime, and it wasn’t because I didn’t love the person I was lying to. It was because I loved them too much to tell them the hard truth. I didn’t want them to see the worst in me.
“Look, you can keep torturing yourself and thinking that the existence of this kid nullifies everything you knew about your husband. But if Jake did something stupid and careless, that’s all it means. It doesn’t mean he was rotten to the core. It doesn’t mean he didn’t love you. Nothing in life is binary. It also means it’s okay to hate him a little bit—while you grieve him. That’s how it works. All the things will be in your heart all at once. That’s why it’s so goddamn heavy.”
“What made you so wise?” I tease.
“It’s all the years, my dear. I know I don’t look it, but I’m no spring chicken.” She bats her eyelashes and cocks a grin, and I laugh as she continues, “People think love is simple and static. But it evolves like our personalities. We are so many people in a lifetime. Your grandfather and I had multiple marriages. During some of them, I loved him something fierce. And during others, I couldn’t stand to listen to the way he chewed. During one of our bad marriages, I met a man who caught my eye—he would come up on the weekends to fish, and I found excuses to spend time with him. I didn’t do anything beyond flirting, but I certainly imagined doing more. And during another one of our bad times, your gramps kissed another woman.”
I gasp, and Gigi raises a brow.
“Don’t look so scandalized, child. I’m not trying to ruin your memory of your grandfather, but I am trying to show you that by hiding our mistakes, we teach our kids to hide theirs. We reinforce shame. Sometimes it’s helpful to learn there are no heroes, just humans.”
“I can’t see it. Gramps? He worshipped you.”
“Of course he did. But it doesn’t mean he wasn’t a knucklehead.”
“What happened?” I struggle with reorienting my version of mild Gramps with this one—imperfect, disloyal.
“Well, your gramps confessed, came to his senses, and stayed the hell away from Gertrude. He also stopped chewing so damn loud, and I snapped out of my little infatuation with Martin. And we forgave each other and chose to keep loving each other.” She sighs, catching my gaze. “I know you and Jake don’t get to keep loving each other. That’s the worst of it. You can’t forgive and forget, because you’ll forever be stuck in the remembering, reeling from the worst moment of your marriage. But who knows. Maybe Jake was innocent in all this, and his wicked mother found a way to clone him. Or drugged him and had him inseminate some unsuspecting gal so she’d have a new young pawn. You never know. Stranger things have happened.”
“Yeah, on soap operas.” We both cackle, and somehow I feel better about all of it. Well, most of it, anyway.
“What are you going to do about this boy? He’s a sweet kid, and we could use some more excitement in the Bell clan. Our family has always been a bit too small and nuclear.”
Only Gigi would think a family needs an illegitimate love child to keep things interesting. “I’ll tell Tess and Miles . . . soon, I think.” But I’m no closer to knowing how to break the news. I wish they could settle into Suncrest and heal whatever rift is dividing them. I’m terrified of shaking an already unstable base. The internet is no help, shocking as that is. There are no reputable tutorials on how to introduce a mysterious sibling to your children while they’re grieving the loss of a parent. And I’m not brave enough to dive into a Reddit rabbit hole.