AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

The Other Side of Starting Over

Page 55

by Mara Williams

“What is it?” he asks, a blur of color across the aisle.

I pause with my finger over the preview line, but my stomach is trying to bury itself below the shop floor. I can’t read the email while Simon is studying me—I don’t need an audience. Being in the dark has been agony, but the light may kill me.

I shove my phone in my pocket and keep my head down, taking a beat as my temples throb. My heart is rioting, sending poisoned blood throughout my body. I never knew how much shock, loss, and betrayal could physically hurt.

“It’s nothing.” I look away, but all I can see is the wall of mirrors, reflecting a million haunted versions of me.

“It’s not nothing.” Simon might be a safer focal point than my own shattered reflection, but when I hazard a glance, I think better of it because his hard angles are blurry and warm, sympathy smoothing his exacting features. “Beatrice.”

He says my name like a plea.

“I just got the paternity test results.”

“Oh.” He chews on his bottom lip, maybe to stop himself from saying the wrong thing. But I don’t think there is a right thing.

I hear my words played back, and the absurdity of my situation lands. “God, I sound like a Maury Povich episode.” I spit out a maniacal laugh. “How is this my life?”

I feel Simon’s heat as he steps closer, and his voice is kind when he says, “It’s not your life. It’s just a chapter.”

I give him a small smile, and he offers a sympathetic one in return. “A shitty one. Ending on the worst cliff-hanger.”

“You didn’t read it?”

I shake my head. “I thought waiting was the worst, but at least I didn’t have to make any decisions. I didn’t have to tell the kids. But if it’s confirmed?”

“If it’s confirmed, then you get to tell them they have a brother.” Simon’s words are raw, like it took him all the generosity he could muster to say them aloud. My kids could find themselves with another brother, and Simon knows what it’s like to lose one. I understand why he’d see the bright side to my black hole.

“And I have to tell them that the father they idolized was unfaithful to me, lied to us all, and neglected his other son.” The memory of Jake telling the kids our meet-cute makes my heart hurt. It was love at first sight. There was never anyone else for me, he’d said. “The math is damning.”

Simon crosses his arms and widens his stance. “So you’re going to pretend the answer isn’t in your inbox.”

“I’m going to wait until I get home and read it alone.” I will handle my life crisis in whatever way I choose, thank you very much.

“If you think that will be easier.” But he sounds unconvinced.

I imagine opening it while sequestered in the attic, a floor away from Tess and Miles, separated by thin walls that won’t dampen my sobs.

“It won’t,” I concede.

It’s quiet in the shop after hours. Gone is the hum of customers chatting, the bell chiming, or traffic from Main Street. The silence is fraught with Simon’s weighty gaze and my conscience berating me about the ethics of delaying the revelation and clinging to my family’s fragile peace.

Because I think I know the truth already. I’m not sure I ever really thought Jake’s ghost went to buy a screwdriver at Ace Hardware. I think I knew the truth the moment River swung open the door at Faye’s house, or earlier, when I saw him hopping into the car outside the shop.

“What do you need? Do you want me to leave?” Simon asks, and it’s a kindness, I suppose, even though solitude is the last thing I want. I’m alone in this, but I find I don’t want to be alone right now.

“I need a drink.”

As soon as I say it, Simon is gone, striding through the aisles and into the office. I wonder if he misheard me, until he emerges with a bottle of something that looks like whiskey. He waves me over, grabs a couple of lowball glasses off a display shelf, and pushes through the back door and into the yard. I follow, grateful that he’s found the one thing that might numb me enough to absorb the news, and relieved to escape the relics and remains trapped inside the shop.

Simon walks toward the large oak, shoving the bottle under his arm and holding the glasses between his thumb and forefinger. He squats again—and seriously, who squats this much during a normal day, unless that’s exactly why his ass looks like that in those jeans—and plugs in an extension cord. The yard glows with the light from the dozen chandeliers I hung up last week.

“When did you do that?” I’m enchanted by the splendor of the lights flickering like fireflies in the canopy. The space is transformed from tired to radiant, and it’s a small burst of brightness to drown out the darkness of my mood.

“You did that.” He sets the bottle and glasses on a wrought iron end table. “I just plugged them in.”

“They’re beautiful,” I whisper. I hadn’t even known those old chandeliers would work. They were in various states of disrepair, with chipped, rusted, missing pieces. I was going for the appearance of opulence; Simon made it authentic. He must have stretched cables and cords—and worked for hours to make them usable.

“You were right. This place needed a facelift. You have some good ideas, for a nepo baby.” He grins, and I have an irrational urge to find out what his smile—his real, full smile—tastes like. I want to experience the grit of his five-o’clock shadow against my chin. I want to feel something other than crushing anxiety. I shiver at the impulse and look away. My trauma response is horny, apparently.