AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

The Other Side of Starting Over

Page 42

by Mara Williams

“Oh, hi.” It’s probably ridiculous that I sound surprised. I asked him to meet me here, after all.

“So, what do I need to do?” River’s posture is stiff and his brows are furrowed; he’s tense in a way that Jake rarely was.

“Do you spend a lot of time here?” I ask instead.

River follows my gaze over the lake as it wrinkles in the lackluster breeze. It’s stained glass, glimmering in the bright morning light. Later, when the afternoon wind inevitably roars to life, the surface will get its hackles up, responding to the disturbance with white-tipped waves, throwing kids off paddleboards and making a feast of water-skiers. But for now it’s placid, blameless.

“What for?” he asks.

To whittle away the long, hot days of childhood. To conquer your fears. To meet your soulmate. I say none of these things, but I can’t help but wonder about the childhood River didn’t have. He’s too young not to be able to imagine the joy this place could conjure.

“Do you need to draw blood or something?” River asks when the silence has stretched thin enough to tear.

I shake my head, drawing out the small box the company sent. “Just a cheek swab.”

I walk to a picnic table and sit before placing the box on the tabletop and opening it carefully.

River settles with a few feet between us. His body language is guarded, arms crossed, shoulders lifted, jaw tense.

“It’ll be quick,” I assure him and unfold the instructions. “We collect your sample, Jake’s, and then send it back. They’ll contact me in two weeks or so.”

“Umm,” River hedges. “Not to be rude or anything, but how will you collect my dad’s? I mean, since he’s dead and all.”

I bristle at his casual use of “dad,” but force a smile. “His hairbrush. And if that doesn’t work, I can swab my son instead.” I unsheathe a long Q-tip, careful not to touch the cotton. When I hand it to River, he follows the instructions, scraping his cheek before handing it back.

“That’s it?”

“That’s it.” I repack the test kit, tucking the box under my arm as I stand, but River stays seated.

“Is this somewhere you’d hang out with my dad? Faye told me you guys knew each other when you were young.”

“We met right here when we were fourteen.”

“That’s wild.”

He’s right. To think of Tess or Miles meeting their future partner at this age would freak me out. Jake and I were an anomaly and, if current events were any indication, a cautionary tale.

“What was he like?” The vulnerability in River’s voice entices me to sit again, settling with my back against the table.

River’s appearance in my life has complicated an already impossible season, but I can’t bring myself to blame him. If he’s telling the truth, this fiasco will leave a bigger impact on his life than mine. He’s a boy without a dad, without the opportunity to ever meet him. I can spare some memories for him. I have decades’ worth in the vault.

“He was desperately funny, and loud, and messy. . . He loved music, especially live local bands and festivals. He was obsessed with sports and could become invested in anything—curling, darts, bowling. I once caught him watching a caber toss competition in the middle of the night.”

The wind picks up, rustling the leaves of the trees around the picnic site, and I shake away the mundanity of the memories.

“What was he like as a dad?”

I don’t know how to answer this without hurting River, because the word that comes to mind is proud. In Jake’s eyes, the twins were the best competitors on every team, the smartest kids in class, and the most beautiful children in town. But I don’t know how to reconcile that with his desertion of River, if that’s what he did.

Look at these perfect people we made, he’d say. Everyone else is jealous of how cool our kids are, he’d whisper in my ear at school events.

“He was a good father.” It’s the truth—at least, the truth as I understood it weeks ago.

“My mom wouldn’t talk about him. I asked a bunch of times.” River fidgets with his hands, flicking each finger against his thumb in a repetitive pattern.

“I imagine that hurt, but she probably had her reasons.” I surprise myself by defending a woman who may have been sleeping with Jake while I was blissfully unaware, trusting him with my heart. But maybe she didn’t know about me either.

“Not good ones.” He bounces his knee, and the motion shakes the wooden bench before he forcibly stills it with his palm. “Would you hide something so important from your kids?”