AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

The Other Side of Starting Over

Page 37

by Mara Williams

“I miss that Jake was always so sure about everything that he’d silence my doubts.”

Simon lets that breathe for a moment, and the truth of my statement settles in my bones. I’m tired of making decisions steeped in uncertainty. I’m exhausted by the weight of my family’s burdens.

“I miss how Elias was willing to be my social armor, picking up friends who accepted me, too. Even though my mouth jumps off the cliff a lot.”

Simon is starting to make some sense. I understand sibling dynamics. Miles has been able to float beside Tess, a straight man to her showgirl. He would feel lost without her, and she without him.

“I miss Jake’s laugh. His real one. He had one that was polite and polished, but when his guard was down, his true laugh was so loud it was startling and always made me giggle.”

“Elias was annoyingly smart, but I miss getting to tease him about his stupid moments. He ruined about five microwaves by trying to heat something with tinfoil. He kept losing his cell phone by putting it on the roof of his car and once flew to San Jose, Costa Rica, instead of San Jose, California.” Simon chuckles, a warm sound that I want to feel up close.

I’m envious of Simon’s affection for his brother and the straightforward simplicity of missing someone for all their good. Simon has a five-year head start, sure. But his brother probably didn’t leave him destitute and dealing with a chain of betrayals.

“I miss thinking that my husband wasn’t hiding things from me,” I blurt, surprising myself.

Simon’s quiet for a moment. “Is this about what Faye was telling you? Because I’m pretty sure that woman would lie on her own son’s grave.”

The air-conditioning rattles on, and it gives me the courage to speak into the abyss, as if white noise can absorb a confession.

“I’m pretty sure Jake had a son he never told me about,” I whisper.

Simon lets that statement sit so long that it marinates in the stillness. It gives me time to regret saying it aloud, to wish I could pluck it out of the air and wipe it from the record.

“This is one of those moments that I’m afraid I might say the worst thing,” he says finally.

“The worst thing was me telling you. Could you pretend I didn’t?” But I said it aloud for the first time and the sky didn’t cave in, and for some reason, I want to know. “What were you going to say?”

“I don’t want to speak ill of the dead.”

“Just say it.” I prop my head in my palm.

“You won’t get angry?” It sounds like a preemptive apology.

“When has that ever stopped you?”

He laughs, and it’s rough and loose. “I was thinking that it’s a good thing you’re the parent your kids have left, not the one who wouldn’t claim one of his own.”

I let that sentiment land, swallowing the impulse to guard Jake’s memory. But after a moment’s hesitation, I find I don’t want to. I’ve been defending, convicting, and missing Jake, filtering through my conflicting emotions to ensure I let only love slip through for the kids’ sakes, and I’m exhausted by trying to restrain my ambivalence. It’s nice to have an audience who won’t be appalled if my widowhood doesn’t match their saintlike expectations.

Besides, maybe Simon is right. I can’t imagine how Jake would have held up if the roles were reversed. If I had died and he was the bankrupt single parent, I don’t know if he would have been able to make the hard choices to save our family. Jake was light and joy. He turned his back on his demons until they overtook him. Would he have been able to withstand the pain to carry our family through it? Or would he have run from the darkness, leaving the twins to drown in his wake?

I don’t know if Jake could have handled it. And that—not the doubt about Jake’s honesty and River’s paternity—may be my biggest disloyalty of all.

“I think it would have been better if my kids had both parents” is the only truth I can muster.

“Of course. But it’s obvious you’re a good mom, Beatrice.” When he says my name, I feel it in my toes. “And I guess after Elias died, I started to play all these what-if scenarios in my head. What if we hadn’t rented that houseboat, what if his jackass groomsman hadn’t dared him to do a backflip off the second story, what if I could have convinced him not to do it, or what if I found him sooner—all the what-ifs that would have left us intact.”

I flinch at all the sharp specifics of his brother’s death, filling in the gaps with even uglier images. I don’t want to know more and don’t want him to have to tell me. Relaying the gruesome details demands that the grieving pry open wounds and show them off to satisfy voyeurs. I know the details of Jake’s death and wish I didn’t. So, no, I’m not going to ask Simon for more. “I’ve haunted myself with all the ways I could have stopped what happened.”

“Me too,” Simon whispers, and he feels so close that the words almost brush my ear. “That doesn’t end. Or maybe it does, if you’re better at grieving than I am.”

“Is there a right way?”

Simon sighs. “I don’t know. All I know is if my parents had to lose a son, it shouldn’t have been Elias.”

“Simon,” I whisper, my stomach dropping. “That’s not true.”

“You didn’t know Elias.”