AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

The Other Side of Starting Over

Page 31

by Mara Williams

“How about you don’t piss me off?”

“Whoa. Let’s not get carried away.” He raises his palms in surrender. “We should make sure this agreement isn’t doomed to fail.”

A laugh escapes before I can think better of it. “Then promise not to piss me off willfully, intentionally, and with premeditation.”

He shakes his head, grinning now. “Hmm.”

“Never mind. You’re impossible.”

He laughs, tilting his head to catch my gaze, his dark eyes shiny and warm. “I think I can keep it to second-degree aggravation.”

I ignore the way my chest heats with his unexpected fondness and familiarity.

“And I can give you the benefit of the doubt. But you have to promise to be careful with money. You can’t buy any more espresso machines or other luxuries with shop money.”

“Hey, I bought that and gave it to the shop.” He looks wounded. “Your dad was drinking this terrible bitter shit from a stained carafe and complaining about heartburn.”

“Oh,” I say. “Well, I can tell you have fancy taste, and I need us to be frugal. I want to make sure you don’t—”

“Fancy taste?” He scoffs.

“Those boots,” I say. “Your jeans.” I point to the evidence.

“You know how many pounds of cheap clothing wind up in landfills each year? I buy things that last and then wear them until they fall apart.”

“Okay. Sorry,” I say, chastened. I probably shouldn’t have let on that I’ve noticed the label on his jeans, which is suspiciously close to his ass. It’s none of my business anyway. “Then can you promise not to hide stuff from me or keep me in the dark?”

His face straightens, and he tilts his head, studying me. “Why would I do that?”

I don’t know why men do anything—why Jake took money from the business, why he lied, why he was hiding so much from me in his last few months. It’s hard to really know the men closest to you, let alone one you’ve just met.

Simon doesn’t break eye contact, and I’m too struck to look away, mesmerized by the way his eyes crinkle at the corners when his smile is genuine, too disoriented by the intensity with which he’s looking at me.

“I don’t know. I mean, I don’t really know you at all,” I say.

“You’ve made a lot of assumptions,” he says. “Maybe we should get to know each other.”

It feels almost suggestive—because of his deep voice and heavy gaze—but it must be an apology of sorts, a do-over that opens the dialogue he shut down the other day. I settle against the seat, breaking the spell, reminding myself to keep it light. He might put up his guard again if I dig into his background. I flip through the list of dinner questions Jake would use to engage the twins once they became monosyllabic teens whose answers to the standard “How was your day?” became a combination of grunts and “fines.”

“All right. What’s something you hate that everyone else loves?”

Simon looks startled by the curveball question, his brow furrowing before he visibly relaxes into the seat. “Sunshine.”

I gasp. “What are you, a vampire?” He chuckles in response, and the sound takes about a decade off his demeanor. “That answer does not make it easier to trust you.”

He shrugs. “I sunburn easily, don’t like to sweat unless I’m exercising, and grew up in Seattle.”

I’m silent for a full ten seconds. “You’re saying you don’t like happiness.”

His chuckle turns into a laugh, and I love the sound of it. Laughter has been a missing melody in my life lately. “Same question back at you.”

“Carnivals, the county fair, anything that combines concrete, crowds, fried food, and rides that wouldn’t pass a safety inspection.”

“You’re cheating. No one loves that.” He folds his arms across his chest and hitches one knee up on the seat as he turns to me.

“Tell that to my kids.”

“Hmm,” he says, eyeing me like I exploited a loophole. “Then what’s something you like that no one else does?”