The Other Side of Starting Over
Page 22
Simon nods toward me, and I hold up a hand at River, half in greeting, half to keep him at bay, and I’m grateful he freezes where he is. His hunched posture suggests trepidation rather than aggression, and my heart settles a bit. I don’t know whether he’s here as a friend or foe, but either way, he’s saving me another visit to Faye’s to track him down. I need to talk to him—away from Faye. Now is as good a time as any.
I hand the bag to the customer and thank them for coming in, but my smile is brittle.
I catch Simon’s eye. He studies River and then me, his brows pinched.
“I’m going to step out for a bit.” I don’t wait for Simon’s acknowledgment or protest before I grab my purse and nod to River to lead the way out onto Main Street. I hitch my purse higher on my shoulder, a nervous tic, as he shoves his hands deeper into his pockets.
“I heard you yesterday,” he says. “Not saying I believe you, but I figure we should talk.”
“Do you like ice cream?”
“Huh?” He sounds so young, barely older than the twins.
“There’s a new ice cream shop down the street. Have you been?” It’s run by a couple who is relatively new in town, and it has a private patio in the back, away from the wandering eyes of shopkeepers and old friends. I want to avoid stores on Main Street run by long-term Suncrest families. All my closest friends from childhood ran away to bigger cities, but I’m sure there are a few acquaintances still around. Eventually, the entire town will know I’m back, but I’m not ready for the pity or canned condolences. I’d like to hide for a bit and adjust to my new reality in solitude. And I don’t need any of them to connect the dots by seeing River and me together.
“Nah,” he says. “I’ve only been on this side of the lake twice—to pick up a screwdriver, and then when I had to return it the next day because I got the wrong one.”
I’m relieved he doesn’t hang out in Suncrest often. Hopefully it means the kids aren’t likely to run into him. If they did, I doubt they’d think anything of it. At least, I hope not. They wouldn’t have Jake’s young features memorized; they’ve seen only a handful of old photos. Besides, Jake had filled out as an adult, wore a beard, and had aged, of course. But it’s still unsettling that River is walking around with their dad’s profile. My husband’s smile.
“You want to check it out? My treat,” I say.
River casts an apprehensive glance my way before looking at his feet. “Um. Yeah, sure.”
After a few stilted moments of footsteps and silence, we push through the doors of Cream and Cone, greeted by cool air and the scent of sugar. The creamery’s vintage mint-and-brown aesthetic and bright storefront elevate Suncrest from haggard to touristy.
River orders cookies and cream without hesitation, and it’s another splinter under my skin, but I remind myself that ice cream preferences aren’t genetic, and it’s a popular favorite. So what if it was the only flavor Jake ever ordered? We take our cups to the patio, the iron chairs scraping against the bricks in a discordant chorus before we settle across from each other.
It’s disorienting to see a face so like one I often traced with my fingertips, so like expressions I memorized, and yet River’s visage is scrambled into the shape of something alarming.
“How long have you been staying here?” I take a spoonful of mint chip, trying to sound casual, although this meeting is anything but, and I hope he doesn’t notice my hand shaking. If he’s working with Faye on a con, he’ll be emboldened by my fear. But if he’s an innocent kid caught up in this mess, maybe it’s better if he knows I’m human, too. Maybe seeing each other’s humanity will save us both.
River eyes me while he swallows a bite. “Not long.”
“You’re living with Faye?”
He nods, and I can’t help but evaluate every gesture for a glimpse of Jake, the downward tip of his chin, the stubborn set of his jaw, and the way he darts his gaze to the side. Even his hair falls the same way. Do I even need more proof?
But I could be filling in the gaps of my memories with grief, and fear, and speculation. It’s been twenty years since Jake was his age. And months since I held him, weeks of imagining his voice, his touch, the sounds of his footsteps. I’m not sure I can trust myself not to conjure him from the sheer force of my despair.
“Where’d you grow up?”
“My mom and I moved around a lot,” he says after a brief hesitation, or perhaps calculation. He bounces his knee, and it shakes the iron table. His anxiousness is fueling mine.
“Where’s she now?” I can’t not wonder about her. How would she and Jake have met? Did they go to college together? Meet at a party one night? Did they date, or hook up once? Were they in love? That last thought makes me physically ill.
“I don’t want to talk about my mom.”
“Okay.” No small talk. Got it. “What makes you think you’re Jake’s son?”
“I don’t think it. I know it. I’ve seen photos. I look exactly like him.” He sticks his spoon in his bowl. It’s hard to be outraged over ice cream, I realize, which is perhaps why I brought him here.
“You do look a lot like him.” I try to keep my voice neutral. “Have you always known about Jake, or did you just find out? Did your mom tell you recently?”
“I told you—”
“You don’t want to talk about your mom.” I’m not going to get anything out of this kid.
I take a deep breath, preparing myself for the next question I need to ask. It’ll give me a timeline and enable me to count backward and figure out whether River was conceived when Jake and I were away at separate universities, together in our hometown, or already building a life together. It’ll tell me how naive I’ve been. “When’s your birthday?”