AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

The Other Side of Starting Over

Page 10

by Mara Williams

Well, that tracks. “That’s bold, since my parents banned her from the store over twenty years ago.”

“What’s the story there?”

“She worked for them, stole from them, and sued them for wrongful termination. It was more expensive to fight it . . . My parents settled. Salt in a wound and all that.” I watch Simon for a reaction, but he’s unreadable. She charmed my parents, who thought they’d hit the jackpot by finding a mature adult who could manage the store without one of them present. But when valuable pieces went missing, and the till was off, they discovered her charisma was covering something more sinister. My parents didn’t have a good inventory system and had no proof it was her. But they knew.

“Was that before or after you married her son?” Simon asks, and I bristle at the implication of disloyalty—and poor judgment.

“I met Jake before I knew who his mother was.” At fourteen, it didn’t matter who his people were or whether my parents approved. As soon as we made eye contact at the lake, I saw our future spool out before us like a highlight reel.

Simon casts an apprehensive glance my way and clears his throat. “Your parents didn’t tell me your husband died, just that you were moving home to get back on your feet. I’m sorry for your loss.”

I think every person should take grief training as a required course in high school. I didn’t lose my husband; I didn’t misplace him. He isn’t going to turn up when I do spring-cleaning or flip the couch cushions. He was crushed in the mangled metal of his midlife-crisis car and bled out before the ambulance arrived. And passed is too passive a word to describe Jake’s death. He went out like he lived: in a hurry.

I can’t bring myself to mutter an acknowledgment of the bare minimum of human compassion Simon has offered. I’m not here to assuage his discomfort with the ugly reality of my loss.

Instead, I fixate on the more interesting part of his statement. “My parents didn’t tell you?” They work with him every day, trust him enough to let him take over purchasing, and didn’t mention their son-in-law died or that their daughter would be his new boss.

“I assumed divorce or job loss or something, and I didn’t want to pry.”

Simon watches the road, both hands on the wheel, and I wonder if he’s driving more cautiously with us in the car. The mention of fatal car crashes would do that to anyone. He pulls up to a stop sign at the end of the main drag.

This town is about six flower boxes short of charming. It’s not much of a tourist destination; instead, it’s a pass-through for travelers as they head into the High Sierras for greener pastures—Tahoe to play and ski, Yosemite to marvel at the majestic redwoods and towering waterfalls. Everything in Suncrest is underwhelming: our modest lake, unimpressive pines, and our dying downtown. Vacant storefronts litter Main Street in between the stubborn survivors like Bygones on Main, Genevieve’s Candy Shop, and Suncrest Diner. Otherwise, there’s a rotating crop of short-term shops that shutter faster than poppies wilt in the California sun. It’s too hard to compete with the chain restaurants and strip malls right outside town. I worry the wave of generic new construction will soon swallow Suncrest whole.

Simon turns onto the pine-bordered road toward my parents’ house. The brush is dry and brittle—parched at the end of the long and relentless summer. The driveways that splinter out from the street are in various states of disrepair, leading to homes that have seen better days. The palette of the landscape is monochrome—in various shades of russet, taupe, and tan.

I sneak a glance in Simon’s direction, enthralled by the angles of his profile: straight nose, prominent cheekbones, deep-set dark eyes. He’s graying at his temples, even though the rest of his hair is still so dark that it’s almost blue. His jaw is sharp, clean shaven, but slightly uneven. His haircut is precise, and his eyebrows create a dark slash across his discontented face. I’m startled to discover Gigi was right—he is handsome, in that unconventional way men are allowed to be. His face is more beautiful than the sum of his harsh features. He’ll probably get hotter as he ages, too—a gender inequity I resent with my whole chest. I haven’t bothered to classify men as attractive or unattractive in forever. It’s disconcerting to notice now. I look away, staring ahead at the winding road as the light flickers through the pine trees like a strobe, blinding me before casting the car in shadow.

That sensation roiling in my gut is guilt, I think. Guilt that I’m alive to dispassionately notice another man’s nice jawline and soft mouth. Guilt that I’ve been a widow for less than a year, and my skin crackled alive at the uninterested touch of an unpleasant man. Guilt that I let Faye get under my skin. Because she’s probably lying. She must be lying.

But there’s no explanation for how she knew Jake and I argued. And who the hell was that kid who got into her car?

“When Faye came in before, was she with a teenage boy? Maybe seventeen, eighteen?” I ask.

“Not that I remember,” Simon says. “But it was a while ago, and I was more concerned with getting her out of there without making a scene in front of the other customers. Who is he?”

“I don’t know, actually,” I say.

I’m not comfortable sharing more. I don’t know Simon. I don’t trust him. I appreciate that he didn’t let me faint and hit my head on the sidewalk, but that’s a low bar. I can’t overlook that he refused to answer my questions about his background and has been unnecessarily combative.

Also, I’m wary of my parents’ judgment. After hiring and firing Faye, they held a grudge but never learned their lesson. Faye was the only financial scammer they hired, as far as I know, but they’ve employed a long list of slackers and flakes. Annalise abandoned her shift at the annual Pine Festival, a major money maker for the store, to go see a Phish concert. Gianna homeschooled her three kids from the shop while on the clock. Dougie sold a first edition of Catcher in the Rye for two dollars and routinely overslept his afternoon shifts. Nix had a lucrative side hustle selling pot from the parking lot.

Simon needs to earn my trust.

I turn away and look out the window as we bypass clusters of blue mailboxes along dirt roads. Suncrest hasn’t fallen prey to vacation rentals in the way of other California mountain towns, but we do have a committed group of weekenders who built their cabins on the cheap and love the quiet of a town that’s neither bustling nor beautiful. It’s only a three-hour drive from the Bay Area, which I’ve reminded the twins more times than I can count. We’re not cut off from the world, even if it does feel like we’re a world away.

There isn’t much to do here, though, which Tess and Miles have complained about relentlessly. There’s the lake, of course, but the water is cold, even in the hottest summer months, because it’s formed by snow runoff from the Sierras, and the beach is strewn with a dozen layers of pine needles. My earliest memories entail running barefoot to the water’s edge, wincing at the sting of sharp needles underfoot, and squealing at the bite of the water. But I also remember swimming to the dock, lounging in inner tubes during endless summer days, and learning how to stand-up paddleboard with Jake’s hands on my hips for support, his cool, damp fingertips making my skin sizzle as he toyed with the strings of my bikini.

There are infinite memories of him here, where we fell in love, fell apart, and fell back together.

We pull up to my parents’ extended A-frame, the sound of Hall & Oates drifting out through the open windows. Tess and Miles blurt obligatory thank-yous before they race toward the cabin and up the porch steps.

“Thank you for the ride,” I say. “I really am fine, though.” If we’re going to be working together, he needs to see me as a worthy adversary, not a weak link.

“Hmm,” he says, his hands still on the steering wheel. “You felt fine when I was holding you upright.”

I clutch the door handle in my right hand, hating that I have to ask a favor from this guy. “Look, I’d appreciate it if you kept this whole thing to yourself.”

“Because you’re fine.” He turns to me, his gaze searing and smart, crawling over my skin as if I’m in a hospital gown that doesn’t close, and he’s diagnosed me via visual exam.