Page 1
1
ENGLAND, 1814
Lord Rupert Milnes did not like losing. He disliked criminals even more. Yet here he was—defending one.
His fingers drummed lightly against the worn wooden table as he forced himself to breathe evenly. Steady, Rupert. You’ve crawled your way out of worse corners. But even that small reassurance did little to quell the twisting in his gut as he studied the petit jury of men. They avoided his eyes. Every last one of them.
One wrung his hands until the knuckles blanched. Another dabbed sweat from his temple with a frayed handkerchief. Several glared openly at Rupert’s client, Mr. Bourke—a sharp-faced, sour-tempered man whose scowl had been fixed since the trial began.
They’ve convicted him already, Rupert thought grimly. Before they have even conferred with one another.
The judge, a heavyset man with a bristling white wig and black gown, cleared his throat and fixed Rupert with a weary, impatient stare.
“Is there anything you wish to say before the jury confers to decide your client’s fate, my lord?”
“Yes,” Rupert replied, rising as he adjusted the itchy gray horsehair wig. “There is, Your Honor.”
“Well then, make it quick,” the judge said, pinching the bridge of his nose.
Rupert strode towards the jury box, his boots echoing sharply on the oak floor. The scent of herbs and scented flowers, used to mask the smell of unwashed prisoners, mingled in the air of the Old Bailey. He slowed at the railing, clasping his hands behind his back.
In a calm, steady voice, he began, “Mr. Bourke is not a good man.”
A collective intake of breath rippled through the room. Even the judge snapped his gaze up.
Rupert ignored them and gestured to his client, who was staring daggers at him.
“He is, in fact, a criminal. A man who has spent years in prison for theft. This is undeniable. That,” Rupert said, letting the word hang, “is a fact. And in courts such as this, we are meant to examine facts.”
He paced slowly before the jury, letting the scrape of his boots fill the silence.
“You may not like my client,” he continued. “Truth be told, I do not much care for him either. His hair is slick as if he bathes in lamp oil, and his breath”—he paused deliberately—“could sour milk.”
A few jurors blinked in stunned surprise.
The judge harrumphed. “Is there a point to this performance?”
“There is,” Rupert replied. “If you will indulge me for just another moment.”
With a wave of his hand, the judge said, “Proceed, then.”
Rupert turned back to the jury. “Your task is not to judge whether Mr. Bourke is likable, because he is not. Your task is to determine whether he stole a diamond necklace from Mrs. Walford. A theft that”—he let his tone drop meaningfully—“is punishable by death.”
A hush fell over the courtroom.
He stopped pacing and faced them squarely. “So let us return to the facts. No one saw my client enter Mrs. Walford’s residence. No one saw him holding the necklace. The constable searched his home—top to bottom—and found nothing. This case rests on a single piece of evidence: a footman who saw Mr. Bourke loitering outside the residence.”
Rupert softened his tone. “But Mr. Bourke had reason to be there. A reason that has nothing to do with theft. He was meeting one of Mrs. Walford’s maids—a young woman he has been courting.”
A few jurors shifted, uncertainty stirring at last.
“The Crown wishes you to believe the two of them conspired to steal the necklace. Yet there is no proof of such a conspiracy. None.”
He placed a hand briefly on the railing, leaning forward just slightly. “I beg of you, do not let Mr. Bourke’s past sins condemn him for a crime he did not commit. He is guilty of many things. I do not deny it. But he did not steal that necklace.”
Rupert stepped back and dipped his head towards the judge. “That is all I wish to say, Your Honor.”
The judge exhaled heavily. “Very well. The jury will now confer.”