Page 56
“Are you?” he asks casually.
I whirl on him, the movement making my head spin. “Wh-what’s that supposed to mean?” I sputter. Damn, the Bailey’s is hitting me hard.
He slides his hands into his pockets, classic unflappable Hunter, and shrugs. “If we’re using senseless stereotypes, I might as well call you on your shit.” His look is pointed. “You’ve been friendlier.”
I suck in a bracing breath, but I’m still too hot. Unwrapping my scarf, I say, “I’m sorry if I’m a little protective. She was clearly on the prowl.”
“Please,” he snorts. “I haven’t seen her in months. She was just being cordial.” Then his brows lift. “And you? Protective of me? Since when?”
Since I saw Naomi acting like a cat who found a mouse she wanted to play with.
Since Jackie looked at you like you hung the moon.
Since I saw that picture—
I cut off the line of thinking. Any woman interested in Hunter should make me supportive, not protective.
But that’s what this feeling must be. He’s my oldest friend. I just want what’s best for him, and no one is good enough.
What else could it be?
I squeeze my eyes shut, shaking my head. It feels more stuffed with cotton than the artisanal toys three stands over. When I open them, two blurry Hunters sway before me.
A hand grips my bicep, and heat blazes through my body from where he holds me upright. It pools in my gut, which does a flip.
Fuck. I do not feel great.
Swallowing, I attempt to bring his concerned face into focus. “Forget it. I didn’t mean to scare her off.”
A smirk cuts through his worry. “Yeah, you did.”
I roll my eyes, and WinterFest spirals. “I just wanted a second alone with you,” I manage. “To apologize.”
He lifts the cocoa, examining it. “Is that what this is?” He brings it to his lips, eyes lighting when he tastes the extra merry. He blows out a whistle. “Not bad, as far as apologies go.”
His voice is warm, but his face is too impassive for my liking. Or maybe it’s just blurring with the twinkle lights.
I lean into his hold. “It’s a peace offering. For missing our hike.”
Again, that shrug—like none of it matters. Like he didn’t notice ignoring me for two days after.
“We didn’t have set plans. I was just trying to prevent that vicious cabin fever from setting in. I know how bored you get up here.”
There’s something sharp in his tone. A challenge. Like when we’d race to see who could make it to the top of a tree the fastest—always him, given my fear of heights, unless he let me win.
He’s not letting me win right now. He won’t say it, but he’s drawing a line in the snow.
Stop taking him for granted. Stop fucking around with our twenty-plus-year friendship. Either it matters, or it doesn’t.
If only he knew.
“I’m still sorry—if I gave the impression it didn’t matter.” I step closer, my voice a little pleading. Maybe it’s the Bailey’s—how it makes the fair spin and his touch burn—but I need him to understand. “I was really looking forward to our hike.”
He straightens, confusion dancing across his features. “It was just a hike, Char.”
“Yeah, but I wanted to be there.” Damn, my lips are loose. How often do I actually talk about what I want? My life is steered by what I need, what will keep me safe. But this?
This is true.