Page 26
I spend the next hour hiding in the kitchen with my laptop, falling deeper into a pit of apartment-related despair. Even the non-stop Christmas music blasting from the living room can’t fix it. I’m just glad the noise covered most of my conversation with Brent. Brie already doesn’t understand my relationship; she doesn’t need more ammunition.
“Aunt Charlie!” Avery appears in the doorway, bouncing toward me in a sparkly red sweater dress. “Are you singing?”
My head jerks up. Was I?
I only now realize I’d been singing along to the blaring holiday tunes. My cheeks go a little pink.
“Please.” I gesture at my throat. “That’s not singing.”
“Your voice is so pretty,” Avery says, rocking on her feet. “I like to sing, too!”
She’s so earnest that even though singing is still a sore spot, I smile and face her. “I heard your voice this morning. It’s beautiful. What do you like to sing?”
“Everything. I’m in our school choir,” Avery says proudly. “We have a caroling show in a few weeks. Will you come?”
I’m about to say yes, when I realize I plan to be long gone by then. Gently, I say, “We’ll see. I usually live in the city. I might be back there soon.”
“Oh, okay.” Her face falls, and my heart twists. But then she perks up again and asks, “Want to help decorate the tree?”
Crap. I’m not sure I could get into the holiday spirit if it was injected into my bloodstream. I’d rather drown myself in a glass of wine and StreetEasy listings, but letting Avery down twice in a minute doesn’t sit well.
Connor appears in the doorway, eyes saucer-round. “Wanna do the star?”
All the fight goes out of me. In the background, I spot Brie and Kev pretending not to clock my reaction.
“Yeah, okay,” I exhale. Brie’s brows shoot up in surprise, but Kev grins. “Why the he—heck not?”
Brie smothers a smile as Avery tugs me off my stool toward the living room, where a thousand glittery ornaments are spread across the coffee table.
“Do you like this one?” she asks, picking up an oversized snowflake covered in glitter.
“I do. Did you make that?”
“Uh-huh.” Her chin lifts with pride. “I made it in Kindergarten last year.”
“Wow. It’s awesome. Can I hang it?”
“No!” She clutches the ornament to her chest. “It’s mine. But Mom said this one has your name on it.” She places something in my hand.
A tiny, homemade bell. Familiarity hits like a jolt.
It’s an inverted miniature flowerpot, painted silver and bedazzled within an inch of its life. Just inside the rim, crooked block letters read, “CHARLIE.”
Another ornament plunks down in my hand—its twin, but with less glitter and more beads. A pair, like turtle doves.
As Avery darts off to hang her snowflake, Brie sidles into her spot. “Remember making those?” she asks, tucking her hair behind her ear. “We had fun that day.”
“No.” I shake my head, eyes inexplicably burning again. Maybe I’m allergic to the suburbs. “I don’t.”
“Mom had the supplies waiting when we got home from school, laid out on the table. We made other decorations too, but only these survived.”
I press my lips together. The bright, hand-painted ornaments strike a harsh contrast to everything I remember from this house. Screaming. Slammed doors. God, I don’t even recall decorating a tree together. Things got so strained, towards the end.
The kids and Kev blur around us as they trim the tree. When I finally look at Brie, her brow is pinched.
“Why do you remember things so differently than I do?” she asks.
The burning drops to my chest. I clear my throat.