Page 178
Maybe he still doesn’t.
Either way, he clearly made this decision long before that.
But his house isn’t in Pinegrove. It’s three towns over. Thirty minutes closer to Manhattan. A small distinction, but one that matters.
Amid my dread and heartache, a shred of hope latches onto my heart.
Maybe that distinction wasn’t lost on Hunter, either.
“But he does want these things,” Hannah adds gently. “And at some point, you’re going to have to decide.”
“Decide?”
“Come on, Charlie,” she says with a wry smile. “You two have loved each other since you were five. Hank and I have always wondered when you’d get out of your own way and do something about it. It sounds like you finally have.”
Heat crawls up my neck. “He told you?”
She nods. “But even if he hadn’t, it’s written all over both of you. Always has been.”
“But he left—” My voice cracks. “It sounds like he’s already decided.”
“I know my son.” She lifts my chin with a finger. “He’s not so changeable. And one thing that’s never changed is how he feels for you. It might be quiet, unassuming—” She hesitates. “Unrequited. But he loves you.”
I shake my head, fresh tears snaking down my cheeks. “It’s not unrequited.”
Hannah grabs my hands, squeezing them tight. “Then tell him.”
For a long beat, we just hold each other’s gaze.
And I realize. I thought I was an orphan. No parents, no families.
I’ve had two mothers who love me, all along. And one of them is right here.
“What about tonight?” I whisper. “Did I screw that up, too?”
She gives my hands one more squeeze and lets go.
“If Hunter needs space, I won’t ask him to go to that show. He’d only say yes, but it’d hurt him more to see you and not know where things stand. His love for us has always outweighed any desire to protect himself.”
“Right.” I swallow my tears. “Just—just tell him I stopped by.”
“No. I’m not going to tell him.”
My eyes shoot to hers.
“Figure out what you want first,” she says, the words settling deep in my bones. “Then come back.”
After that, there’s nothing left to say.
The snow falls heavier as I head back across the street, tail tucked firmly between my legs.
Chapter 46
Hunter
Ithrow the van in park and turn it off. It smells like wet dog and dirt and all the less pleasant aspects of my job, but I sit here anyway, breath fogging.
What the hell am I doing?