AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

You Feel Like Christmas

Page 156

by Christine Drummond

I hold my breath, not sure which answer is worse—that she knew and didn’t tell me, or that she didn’t know and Noreen’s sudden appearance has knocked her off-balance.

She shakes her head. “I had no idea.”

My brows shoot up. “Was Brie in on—”

But the piano strikes up, a hush falls over the crowd, and two dozen angelic voices spill like a wave over Evergreen Park, ending our conversation.

I debate tugging Charlie aside to make sure she’s okay, but her gaze is locked on Avery. So I stay where I am, jaw clenched, hand cupping her shoulder, and resign myself to twenty minutes of silent support and stewing.

I haven’t seen Noreen in eight years—not since she sold the house to Brie and moved to Florida. She’s been back for holidays and visits, but we haven’t crossed paths. Despite my friendship with Charlie, our families weren’t close. Honestly, I never thought much about it.

Now, I think of how much I see Charlie and Brie just by living across the street, and I wonder if our families’ past distance was deliberate. If my parents weren’t fans of how the Hayeses raised their daughters, when one was always running to our house in tears.

Or maybe Noreen was resentful that her youngest would rather be with our family than hers.

I glare holes in the back of that auburn head, willing her to turn, to meet my eyes and see my fury. Anger for the woman beside me and what her parents’ marriage—their lack of care for her—wrought. What it taught her she deserved.

What it made her never trust.

Noreen doesn’t turn. It’s for the best. The only thing that’d stoke my rage more is if she met my eyes and didn’t recognize me as the man who held her daughter together when she chose not to. Who became her family when her own parents weren’t.

Who loved her the way they never could.

The only bright spot is when Avery steps forward into a spotlight and opens her mouth. In that moment, I believe in Christmas miracles, because my anger ebbs hearing this child’s pure, haunting voice sing, of all things, “Greensleeves”.

In her, I see Charlie, the girl I loved who sang her heart out at every opportunity. Who stole every stage since we were old enough to stand on them. Until her world was rocked to its very foundation on one such stage.

She’s stayed in the wings ever since.

I’m torn down the middle, wanting to absorb Avery’s solo but needing to see Charlie’s reaction. In the end, the woman I love wins out.

Charlie’s focus on Avery is rapt. She doesn’t so much as blink, her eyes gleaming with unshed tears. She also doesn’t smile, cheeks hollowed with more than exhaustion.

My heart thuds painfully. There’s something terrifying about her expression, like she’s already far away where I can’t reach her.

The second the choir takes its final bow and the crowd’s applause dies, I tug Charlie forward.

“Come on.”

She’s not a kid anymore, and I’ll be damned if I stand by and watch her mom run her out of this town again. Char’s been fighting everyone’s battles for years.

Maybe I can help her fight this one.

“Let’s go say hi.”

I’m jerked to a stop when she refuses to move. Turning, I look at her in confusion.

“We’re not going over there, Hunter.”

I take her shoulders in my hands. “That’s your family, too, Charlie. I know you don’t want to see her, but you can’t let her scare you off.”

Hurt pinches her beautiful features. “I’m not scared, Wells. I just—don’t want to deal with this right now.”

I bow my head, because fuck. If she doesn’t want to do this right now, it’s not my place to push.

But then she adds, “I really can’t handle this. You, with them.”

Oh.