Page 58
“The French Blue was not always French. Its earliest history places it in the eye of a Hindu deity. It was likely stolen from India by a gem merchant named Tavernier. It was he who sold it to Louis XIV. Those who believe in the curse say this was its origin—the god resented the theft of their eye.”
“That is quite an origin story,” said Jennie.
“Of course, that’s all it is. Just a story. When Cartier sold the Hope Diamond to the heiress Evalyn Walsh McLean in the early twentieth century, they played up the sinister history as a selling point—that’s perhaps why it looms so large in current imagination.”
Jennie set the paperweight down. She was buzzing inside. She shouldn’t have finished the coffee so quickly. The swallow hadn’t been leading her on some spiritual journey to find a partner or a fulfilling career or even Pete’s murderer. Her mother’s spirit had put her on the trail of real, actual, life-changing treasure.
Maurice seemed to read her thoughts. “Curse or no—I’m sure you understand that the Midnight Diamond would have immense value in today’s market.”
“I can only imagine.”
He continued: “A number of years ago I purchased a suite of items that once belonged to an heiress of the early twentieth century named Marcella Porter. Have you heard of her?”
Jennie tried to keep her eyes from flicking to the diamond “MP” monogram that twinkled up from Pete’s locket. “Just the basics—that she was a Gilded Age coal heiress who liked to party.”
Maurice chuckled. “A tidy summary. Her family was once the richest in the country. Occasionally some of her belongings come up for auction. I always keep an eye out for them, acquire them when I can. My clients enjoy pieces with a Gilded Age provenance. These were hers.” He gestured to the silver objects on the tray. Little bottles, combs, brushes, and a tiny powder box, all in intricately chased silver.
“They’re beautiful,” said Jennie, unable to imagine using such artful objects for daily grooming. Her own vanity was currently the top of the toilet tank, her modest makeup kit vying for space with Liz’s glittery and abundant eye shadow collection.
He unscrewed the lid of the powder box and carefully removed a folded and yellowed sheet of paper that had been wedged inside. He opened it, revealing a pencil portrait of a young woman looking straight on, her hair falling loosely around her shoulders in dark curling waves. Jennie saw right away what intrigued Maurice about the drawing. The jewel the woman wore, right in the center of her cleavage, looked a lot like the jewel she’d seen in the photograph of Lana LaValle. A lot, in other words, like the Eichenbaum auction description of the Midnight Diamond. Could the two women be the same person? Both had dark hair, both were beautiful. But it was hard to tell—in the photograph Lana had appeared defiant, streetwise, and in control. The woman in this portrait looked like she was inexpertly posing for someone she wanted to sleep with.
“I believe,” said Maurice, “this is a self-portrait of a young Marcella Porter wearing the Midnight. However, there’s no record of the jewel in any of the auctions of her family’s effects.”
Jennie tried to string together the series of events. “But you said that after the Eichenbaum sale, the gem was stolen from an English jeweler and never found? If the Porters acquired it from thieves, it’s not like they could sell it openly, right?”
“You may very well be correct,” said Maurice. “But ever since this picture came into my possession, it’s been a bit of a hobby of mine to try to solve the mystery of the Midnight. Of course, I never really expected to find it. But then, I thought I’d found a lead the other week.” Now he handed Jennie the gold locket on his tray. Pete’s locket.
Maurice explained to her what she already knew. The initials “MP” were spelled out on the front in tiny diamonds. The back was engraved with a date. “1.31.1910,” she politely read aloud.
“The date of a famous ball at the Porter mansion,” said Maurice. “A souvenir. And take a look at the maker’s mark, it’s right here below the engraving.” He handed Jennie a jeweler’s loupe, and she peered through it at the tiny stamp. “LH Co.”
Something clicked for Jennie that hadn’t before. Did “LH” stand for—
Maurice took the locket back. “There used to be an old jeweler called Little Hope on Forty-Seventh Street. When I saw this maker’s mark on the locket, I wondered if Marcella Porter had been a client of theirs. If so, it’s possible they could have been the ones to facilitate any surreptitious buying or selling of the Midnight. But the last proprietors of Little Hope appear to be deceased. I attended a close-out auction of their workshop earlier this month and found nothing of interest. So you can understand my excitement when you brought me this little box so shortly thereafter . . .”
Jennie swallowed. “What a coincidence.”
“I believe, Jennie. That the Midnight Diamond is out there, overlooked by everyone else. It may be masquerading as a sapphire, or forgotten in a bank, or even buried in the middle of Central Park. Anything is possible. And I could really use your help finding it.”
“My help?”
“That’s right. And it starts by you telling me where that beautiful box came from.”
Jennie let the room fall silent as she thought through what to do. This was exactly what Lee had warned of—an important dealer, who’d intended to purchase the thing she’d unintentionally stolen, was now asking her about said stolen object. She considered coming clean, but only for a split second. A visceral reaction coursed through her and told her not to. She viewed her luxurious surroundings. Maurice didn’t need any more money. If anyone had ever needed to find a valuable diamond, it was her.
“I told you,” she said. “It was a gift. I wish I knew more.”
“A gift from Peter?”
“No,” said Jennie. Her eyes went back to the monogrammed locket, and this time she did not hold back her questions. “But while we are on the topic, how did you get that locket?”
“Pardon?”
“Pete showed it to me the day he died. And I personally put it away in his safety-deposit box. And all the jewelry in that box was supposed to be auctioned off for charity.”
Maurice leaned away from her. His smooth tone now touched with irritation. “I bought this locket back in December from a private estate sale. Peter thought he might have a client for it, so I lent it to him on memo. I requested it back from the estate lawyer before the Doyle specialists collected everything for their auction.”
“No, that’s not right,” said Jennie, now committed to her line of inquiry.