Page 21
He dragged a hand through his hair. “Every day I live in that house, I want her more, and every day I remember I have no right to want anything from her yet. I gave her my word I would not touch her until she came to me, and I mean to keep it, if it kills me. Duncan… I begin to think it might.”
It was more than he had said aloud to any living soul in a year, more than he had even fully admitted to himself. Having said it, he felt scoured out and faintly appalled, as though he had lanced a wound he had spent months insisting was not there.
Duncan was quiet for a moment. Then, insufferable friend that he was, he smiled.
“I told you,” he said. “At the wedding. I told the pew at large, ‘That man is finished. He does not know it yet, but he is finished.’ And here you are. The great immovable Duke of Towerlake, who has spent a decade turning away the loveliest women in England with that face like a shut gate, undone at last by his own lawful wife. It is the funniest thing that has happened to me all year, and I include the business with the bishop and the swan.”
“I am so glad my ruin amuses you.”
“It delights me. It restores my faith in a just and orderly universe.” Then Duncan leaned forward, and the laughter went out of his voice, and the thing underneath it that most people never troubled to look for came up plainly.
“Now hear me, because I am about to be wise, and it happens so rarely that you should mark the occasion. You want her to trust you, and you have decided that the road to it is to be faultless, patient, and correct, to give her all the room in the world, never to put a foot wrong, and to wait.”
Duncan shook his head.
“It will not be the answer, James. A woman cannot trust a locked door, no matter how handsome or how well it keeps its promises. She was married off to a stranger who has spent his whole life making sure no living soul can see what he feels. You built yourself that way, brick by brick, when we were young, because your father taught you that showing emotions only handed someone a place to wound you. I watched you do it. And now you are wounded because your wife cannot read a man who has made a life’s work of being unreadable.”
James stared into the fire and did not answer because there was no answer that was not agreement.
“If you want her to trust you,” Duncan said, gently now, “you will have to give her the one thing you have never given anyone in your life. Not patience. Not presents. You will have to let her see you frightened. You will have to stop managing what she is permitted to know about you and simply let her look. It is the most terrifying thing I can imagine asking of you, but it is the only coin she will ever take.”
James turned his tankard slowly on the scarred wood and did not drink.
He had met a great many frightening things in one-and-thirty years and buried every one of them somewhere they could not be reached. Half of him wanted to tell Duncan he was a fool, a romantic, and entirely wrong. The other half, the one that lived in the cold room he did not often enter, knew perfectly well that Duncan was right.
It was the hardest thing anyone had ever asked of him, and he had not the slightest notion of where a man was meant to begin.
“You have read the same page four times, and your lips have stopped moving, which means you are not reading it at all. You are thinking. What are you thinking about?”
Beatrice looked up from the fire. Her sister was watching her over the top of a large leather volume, sharp-eyed and entirely unfooled.
They had claimed the library for the evening, the two of them. Each was curled at one end of a vast sofa before the hearth, with a branch of candles and half the contents of a shelf spread between them.
Beatrice had been getting on famously with her book right up until the moment her mind had wandered. It had slipped out across the dark county after him. She did not know where he had gone, only that he had left the house, and she could not stop herself from wondering.
The house felt different with James gone. It seemed larger and quieter, and somehow less certain of itself. She had come down two hours ago to choose a single book, but she had not chosen one.
She understood now that she had spent the whole of that time listening for the sound of a horse in the yard. She had not once meant to.
“I am thinking that it is well past your bedtime,” she said, “and that Miss Ansley will have my head if you fall asleep over your Latin tomorrow.”
“That is not what you were thinking. You had your faraway face.” Ivy set the book aside and folded her hands with the terrible directness of the very young. “You have been having it a great deal lately.” She paused. “Bea. May I tell you something? You must not laugh because I have thought about it very seriously and it was difficult to arrive at.”
“I would not dream of laughing.”
“I have decided I like him,” Ivy said in a rush, as though confessing a crime. “The Duke. I did not want to, you understand. I had made up my mind at the wedding that I should hate him until the end of my days for what he did to you. I had a whole list of cutting remarks prepared, and it is very hard to hate a person properly when he keeps ruining them. He gave me the boat bed. And the library, this whole library, just for asking. And he sat down beside me over the Latin and did not once make me feel stupid, which no one but you has ever managed. And he told the two great fat dogs they were to mind me, and now they follow me everywhere and sleep across my door. And I never even had to ask. And he sent for your horse and pretended it was nothing.”
She scowled, as though James had cheated at some game she had been winning. “It is extremely inconvenient. I had the list all ready.”
Beatrice’s chest ached and warmed at once. “You are allowed to like him, Ivy. It does not mean you have forgiven what happened before. Both can be true at once. That is the difficulty with people. They insist on being more than one thing.” She reached over and tucked a loose strand behind her sister’s ear. “You have a generous heart. It is one of the best things about you. Do not let anyone, least of all yourself, teach you to be ashamed of it.”
“I know that.” Ivy tucked her feet up and studied her sister in the firelight with those too-knowing eyes. “Bea. You like him too.”
“Ivy.”
“You do. I have watched you. You did not use to. At the start, you looked at him the way you look at a bill you cannot pay. And now you look at him the way you look at Zephyrine.” Ivy said it simply, as the plainest observation in the world. “Like something wild that you have decided, against your own better sense, that you are going to keep.”
Beatrice opened her mouth and found nothing in it. No wry deflection, no cool correcting word, none of the thousand small defenses she had spent a year keeping polished and to hand.