AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

Silent

Page 87

by Bodie Summers

My gaze moves to Daniel slowly, trying to discover exactly what he’s thinking or feeling now that I’ve outed the feelings that have been growing since both of them stepped into my world and got on my language level.

Now I just have to figure out whether I’m going to lose either one of them from the admission…

Or whether my greed has set me up for more than I can handle.

COACH DANIEL CARPENTER

I stare at Elana for a long moment, trying to believe that she just signed what she meant. She likes us both? She’s comfortable enough to tell us that in an effort to defend Ben. Now she’s asking if she’s allowed?

Her eyes hold mine with worry and desire in equal measure while my cock twitches to life. I hate that it’s stirring so easily. I’m not supposed to want her. She’s nearly half my age. I’m supposed to make her safe, take care of her, and shove my own selfish wanting down.

That’s what a good man would do, even one who knows exactly how dangerous it is to love someone. But she doesn’t just want me. She wants Ben too. Ben, who’s age appropriate, who’s obvious about how much he likes her. That could be a good thing.

Sharing her means she’s not fully mine and if she’s not fully mine, then it won’t hurt as much when she inevitably doesn’t choose me or stay with me.

“Dude,” Ben says as Elana re-signs her question.

The hope in her eyes, the way her warmth lingers in my skin, against my side, and the temptation of her mouth, her body, her being her, soft and gentle, utterly unaware of how much she affects me is too much.

She isn’t afraid of me. She trusts me. She sees something worth having in me and that curiosity and…how am I supposed to say no when she looks at me like that? With unashamed desire, licking her bottom lip, eyes getting more and more nervous by the second.

“It’s not a problem,” I whisper, hating how rough my voice sounds.

Elana’s face burns a brighter shade of red. I gently brush my fingers over her shoulder as I lean back. I’m not entirely sure what to do with her now that we have that established.

I clear my throat, stretch my stiff knee, then glance from Ben—he’s obviously delighted—to Elana. She swallows, like she’s waiting to be told she’s in trouble.

“It’s not a problem at all,” I say again, needing to ground myself in the fact that this is real. “No one can control what you want and what you’re interested in. If you want to follow that…If you want to act on it…”

“Then do it!” Ben cuts in brightly. “Touching, kissing, experimenting, anything you’re interested in.”

“Ben,” I warn.

Elana smiles, her eyes crinkling. She signs carefully, so both of us can understand, Does it make you mad? Either of you. That I’m not just interested in one person?

I shake my head. This is the first time she’s been free to want openly and honestly. It makes me, strangely, feel better that it isn’t just me. It feels safer for her to want and like both of us. There’s less of a chance of her getting hurt.

“Hell no. I love this confidence, Elana. Own what you want and what you’re feeling. One life to live and all,” Ben says. “But I’m serious. If you want to experiment…”

I reach over and manage to swat the back of his head without swatting Elana in the process. “Behave. This is not a door you get to kick down.”

“I’m not kicking anything down. I’m laying an offer down at her feet. She gets to pick it up if she wants.”

“This has been a good evening,” I say, looking between them. “Maybe we should call it a night.”

“You’re only saying that because you’re old. Leave us young ones to fun,” Ben teases before winking at Elana. “I’m sure I’m enough entertainment for our girl.”

Elana shakes her head with a slight smile.

He’s going to be insufferable after this. I’m sure of it. It’ll be my job to manage how overwhelming he gets, because Elana is too nice.

This is going to be impossible.

Thirty-one

ELANA

Daniel looks like he’s ready to leave or step in just to keep Ben from tempting me further. But I want to know how it’s like to kiss them.