AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

Magdalene Cruthers Is Going To Hell

Page 81

by Ali Lockhart

Accepting the subject change, Maggie shrugged. “Jack said he is going to meet with him in two days. Something about making Sam sweat out the wait.”

“This all seems rather vicious.”

“I don’t think that he and Pearl are taking this lightly. She’s practically foaming at the mouth.” Absurdly, she felt herself tearing up at the idea.

Theo’s sixth sense, which seemed to be entirely attuned to Maggie’s tear ducts, kicked in. “What’s wrong?”

“Oh, nothing.” She wiped at her nose. “It’s just …” She sniffed. “It’s been so lovely having so many people around, and I haven’t seen anyone else support Tom or Bridgers like this ever.” Theo silently handed her a handkerchief, and she took it, dabbing at her eyes. “I’m so sorry,” she said, laughing through a hiccup. “It seems like I’m always blubbering around you.”

“You can blubber all you want,” Theo said, squeezing her shoulder. “It’s good to get the blubbers out.”

She was truly crying then, mixed with laughing, and pushed her forehead against his shoulder.

“I’m just so grateful for them, and everyone here. I’m just so grateful for you.”

Theo remained quiet, his thumb tracing along her shoulder. “I’m grateful for you, too,” he finally said, and whatever fence had been holding Maggie at bay collapsed, and her sobbing was out of her control now, wracking her entire body with shaking tremors she resented immediately. She was at the mercy of her lungs and eyes and heart, and she didn’t appreciate it one bit.

“Maggie, I’m sorry, love,” he sounded startled and pained; his fright for her made her cry harder, until she was fully leaning her weight onto him. He wrapped his arm tighter around her, pulling her into his lap and rocking her gently like she was a child. “What is it, sweetheart? Did something happen?”

Yes. I met a man I never imagined and now I don’t know what to do.

“I—I—” She buried her face into his neck, gulping down air and trying to breathe in his scent, balance herself on this unsteady ground.

“What, sweetheart?” His hand swept calming circles over her back, and Maggie focused on them, soothing and rhythmic.

“I think I’m in love with you,” she choked out, and refused to move from her spot at his throat. He knew now, and if he threw her off, at least she could slink away with some dignity. Or something.

The silence that stretched on was intolerable, and Maggie made to crawl off him and retreat to safety. He let her squirm for a moment before gripping her arms gently, squeezing once. “Maggie,” he said softly. She kept her eyes cast down, memorizing the curve of his hip against the ruddy brown fallen leaves, the sparse dark hairs on his arm. “Maggie.” His tone hardened, and she looked up. His brow was furrowed, deep wrinkles etched on his face, and his dimple was hiding.

“Maggie,” he said again, his voice melting into the perfect gentleness that had ruined her life in the most extraordinary way. He shook her slightly. “Of course you’re in love with me. We’re in love with each other. You didn’t know?”

Maggie was crying again.

“I’m sorry, sweetheart.” He wrapped his arms around her again, pressing kisses to her hair, her ear, anything he could reach. “I should have said it sooner. I’m sorry. I love you so much.”

Maggie had a very real concern that she was about to faint. “You can’t,” she managed. “You can’t feel the same way, Theo; it’s so big. I feel too much.” She hoped, feebly, those last words had been intelligible. They came out as a sobbing stream, certainly, muddy blurbs from her mouth.

“I’m sorry,” he repeated. “I’m sorry you didn’t know. You should have known from the moment you walked into the shop, looking at me like I was a ghost. I knew it then, and I should have told you sooner.”

“Theo,” she huffed out. “I love Emmy so much.”

And he didn’t respond to that; his chest was too busy heaving as he continued to clutch her to him.

Chapter

Twenty-Six

Bridgers’ uncle initially wanted to go at it alone with Sam, saying that the younger man would probably be more likely to open up to just one other person, but seeing as how the pamphlet and, by extension, the sermon had attacked business owners specifically, Reverend Monet eventually determined Maggie, Tom, and Bridgers all should attend the meeting. He had invited Mr. Stinson and Ned, as well, but both had declined attending, saying they thought too many cooks in the kitchen ruined the soup. Lou, who was expressly not invited, had suggested renaming it the interrogation like a cheap novel, but Reverend Monet had kindly declined, saying he meant for this to be a positive experience for all.

It didn’t look positive for Reverend Myerson, certainly. He sat in the parlor of his small cottage behind the church, a meager offering of baked goods and weak tea on the table. The walls in the—Rectory? Parish? God-shed?—were unadorned for the most part, save for a simple clock hanging on the west wall. All the furniture was sturdy and, in Maggie’s uninformed opinion, could be described as quite ugly. The sofa was comfortable enough, and she settled in, somewhat amused by Sam’s profoundly disconcerted expression.

Reverend Monet cleared his throat, grabbing everyone’s attention. Pearl had been forbidden from attending—her husband had informed her that she was too likely to usurp the meeting, and Bridgers had bravely agreed—and the present group all sat demurely as they waited for the reverends to break the silence.

“Thank you for having us in your home, Reverend Myerson,” Monet said politely, inclining his head. Sam, who was fluctuating between ghostly white and alarming pink, merely nodded. “I’m sure you know why we’re here, and while it pains me to cause you any discomfort, I would appreciate your honesty and candor in this matter.” He paused. “Can you assure me of that?”

Sam’s eyes flicked to Bridgers and Tom, then Maggie. His lips pressed together, and he nodded again, jerkily.

“I asked Miss Cruthers and her brothers to be here today because you have launched what can only be described as a direct assault onto them from the pulpit, something that, I’m sure you won’t be surprised to hear, is very much looked down upon in our faith. Can you explain yourself?”