AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

Magdalene Cruthers Is Going To Hell

Page 78

by Ali Lockhart

“You don’t owe me anything, Theo. I hope you know that.”

“It isn’t about me owing you anything,” he retorted. “I want to do things for you. I want you to understand that you’re important to me. And you have these walls up that I can’t seem to tear down.” He shoved his hand into his hair, exasperated. “You’re a fortress inside a moat. I keep trying but every time I make headway, you shove me out again.”

“I don’t do it on purpose,” she said, feeling small.

Theo fixed his gaze on her, considering for a long, quiet moment. “Maggie. What happened to you?” His eyes didn’t leave hers; she could feel them even when she skittered her own around his face. “Why are you so brittle?”

She smiled tightly and felt a glimmer of amusement at his assessment; it did feel a fragile thing, likely to crack her face. “Nothing happened to me.”

“I don’t believe you.”

“I happened to someone.”

Theo remained quiet, keeping his eyes on her. Giving her a chance to decide.

She drew in a long breath. “You know what I used to do, the séances. You know how easily I lied to people. I always thought—” she cut herself off, the shame flooding her body, plugging up every crack. “I always thought I was doing something good. I had convinced myself that I wasn’t like those people who had taken advantage of my father.”

“Your father?”

In for a penny. “My mother … My mother died when I was eight. A fever of some sort, that took her quickly.” She shook her head when Theo reached out a hand, and he withdrew it quietly. “It’s all right. My father—he was a banker, you know, in Chicago, quite successful—he fell into despair. He never recovered from losing her, and he latched onto the idea of speaking to her again.” She was surprised by the bitterness leeching into her voice; bitterness she certainly had no right to anymore. “He attended panels on spiritualism, invited mediums to our home, even befriended some English charlatan who claimed to have been one of the first people to make contact with Prince Albert after his death. I watched him wither away, Theo, just as I’d watched my mother wither, but slower.” She dropped back onto the bed, her hands in her lap. “He didn’t pay any mind to me, as distracted as he was. And as his health went, so did his mind, and his money.” She smiled, wry. “Mediums are expensive. They bled the family fortune dry. So, I knew, you see, how profitable this business could be. And I never thought for a second that these people were actually making contact with my mother. If they had been, she would have said, August, stop with this foolishness and focus on the living.” She slumped her shoulders.

“Papa died when I was seventeen, and I hopped from family member to family member until … Well, I met Tom and Bridgers, and we went into business together. All sorts of things, at first, hawking tonics and miracle cures, feats of strength, and then I suggested giving readings. I’d watched enough of them to know how to do it. We did it for years, me and Tom and Bridge. Traveled all around, never staying longer than a few days. It was exhausting but we made good money, and it got Bridgers out of street performing. Last spring, we were in Pennsylvania, just outside of Pittsburgh.” The words became thick in her throat; her vision turned hazy. The panic was rising, as reliable as clockwork. She exhaled slowly. “There was a man who asked for a reading.” His face was still clear in her mind—pale, humorless smile, dark eyebrows stark against his skin. “He had lost his son.”

“Christ,” Theo breathed.

“Steel accident.” Maggie swallowed. “The factory burned down. He wanted to talk to his son.”

Theo laid a hand on her knee, squeezing softly. Her mouth was dry.

“I thought I was being—” She stopped. “I thought I was being kind.”

Another squeeze.

“I told him that his son hadn’t felt any pain. That he was safe, and happy. And that he missed his father.” Her chest felt hollow. “He was looking forward to their reunion.”

“You did a good thing, Maggie.”

“The man shot himself.”

Silence spread, slowly pooling around them. Theo’s hand rested on Maggie’s lap, slack.

“He left a note. ‘I’m off to see Jonathan.’ Tom heard about it. He tried to keep me from knowing, but I was always too curious for my own good. I overheard someone at a shop talking about it and I asked.” She always asked. It was one of her worst traits.

“Maggie, it isn’t your fault.” Theo’s voice drifted into her consciousness, and she looked at him. How many times had she heard those words over the past year? They had been whispered, yelled, snapped. Bridgers had said them over and over, holding her while she cried. They bounced off of her, falling to the floor.

“Maggie.” Theo’s voice sharpened and she blinked. “Get out of your head. It isn’t your fault. You didn’t hold the gun to his head.”

“Of course I didn’t,” she said. Her heart’s racing had begun to slow. “I just dangled a carrot in front of him and then watched him bite it.”

“It is entirely unreasonable to even consider that someone would kill themselves after that experience,” he argued. “As we have discussed at length, Magdalene, you are not a mind reader, and there is no way to predict that this would have happened.”

“It isn’t just him,” she said, that hollowness spreading out, unfurling into her limbs. Her stomach was clenching and she knew the nausea would roll in soon. “Who else has it happened to? Who else have I given false hope to? Once you realize that there’s blood on your hands, it’s hard to stop seeing it everywhere.”

Sighing, Theo slid from his seat and knelt in front of her. He held her hands in his, raising them to his mouth and gently kissing her knuckles. “There’s no blood on these, Maggie.” He held her palm to his cheek, and she faintly registered the scratch of his afternoon beard, felt her nausea retreating. “I know you’re hurting. And I’m sorry, sweetheart. I wish I could take that away, and I hate that I can’t. You aren’t wrong to be troubled by it, and I think stopping was the best thing you could have done for yourself and for Tom and Bridgers.” He squeezed her hands. “But, darling, you can’t spend your life with this guilt. I know you can’t shed it immediately, but can we work together to lessen it so it doesn’t affect you so badly?”

There were moments—not many, but moments—when Maggie was convinced that Theo wasn’t real. It was easier to believe he was an illusion or fever dream than a flesh-and-blood man kneeling before her, asking her to share her burden so she wouldn’t be so sad alone.

“I don’t know how,” she whispered.